Jose Luis Castillo an ATG?

[Boofdatruth]

Not an all time great but definantly one of the best, at one time of course.

I agree. You can just be good in my book. Being great, ATG or legend is reserved for the very best.

[El Dominicano]

I agree. You can just be good in my book. Being great, ATG or legend is reserved for the very best.

JLC is the best name on Mayweather resume beating a prime Casa and Chico has proven what kinda of fighter he is. Don't know if I can say ATG but sure as hell one of the best 135 pounders and he'd beat SSM at 135 in my opinion, someone who is an overated 135 pounder.

[Boofdatruth]

JLC is the best name on Mayweather resume beating a prime Casa and Chico has proven what kinda of fighter he is. Don't know if I can say ATG but sure as hell one of the best 135 pounders and he'd beat SSM at 135 in my opinion, someone who is an overated 135 pounder.

Castillo is not the best name on Floyd's resume imo. He was a very good fighter, but not an ATG.

[El Dominicano]

Castillo is not the best name on Floyd's resume imo. He was a very good fighter, but not an ATG.

Who would you say is the best name on Floyds resume?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

the only thing ATG about jlc was his fight wit chico

[Dan...]

Who would you say is the best name on Floyds resume?

Personally I think Oscar is the better name. Given situational factors however I see how you could go with Castillo.

[Boofdatruth]

Who would you say is the best name on Floyds resume?

Dom, it's hard. Dlh pops out at you, Chico, Castillo, Hatton. I'd pick Chico.

[Pico Hollywood]

Dom, it's hard. Dlh pops out at you, Chico, Castillo, Hatton. I'd pick Chico.

Castillo is a better name imo.

all around better fighter than my man chico..

[El Dominicano]

Dom, it's hard. Dlh pops out at you, Chico, Castillo, Hatton. I'd pick Chico.

JLC had better skillz then all of them. He didn't just go in and then throw punches he'd actally go in throwing. His stamina power and ability to cut off the ring was GREAT. He was a very good body puncher. Chico on the other hand would depend on his power like we've seen in the Freitas fight...he didn't seem to care if he was getting outbox'd he'd just wait for a K.O...JLC wasn't like that.

[Boofdatruth]

Castillo is a better name imo.

all around better fighter than my man chico..

I don't see what he does better than Chico. What did he do better?