Jose Luis Castillo an ATG?

[Boofdatruth]

Who did better against Floyd

This isn't the difference in their careers, and I'm a Floyd fan. One guy fought Floyd in his weight, and the other fought Floyd at their weight.

[El Dominicano]

Dom is my boy, and he is down with the Co. If he says yes, JLC had more skills than Dlh, don't anyone question his word. Dom, I have to question your word. Are you serious

Yes JLC threw better punches. Everytime DLH swung his biceps would be hitting Floyd and his forearms and hand would be behind Floyd. JLC threw shorter punchs and wen't to the body better. Not to mention he'd tie up Floyd and actally land. DLH couldn't do that and again DLH would go in then throw punches instead throwing while going in. JLC was better at cutting off the ring and when he did...he actaully did something. DLH rarely did and when he did he couldn't land.

[El Dominicano]

Is this some type of knock on chico Dom? That was his style. Castillo did the same thing lol.

Oh c'mon you kidding me. JLC didn't do that. Notice that Chico fought Mayweather the same way he fought Freitas thats a FACT you gotta admit. JLC never depended on his POWER to a POINT where he'd just wait to land a good punch. He'd try and win rounds. Chico on the other hand was GREAT using that style and till this day I can't believe he made it FAR doing so. Trust me I ain't dissing Chico cuz in my opinion he'd beat any 130-135 pounder right now and so would JLC.

[Nicky_Hatton]

I don't have time for all that ****, your a boxing fan if you watch Castillo then you post in this thread.

Fair cop,

I wouldn't say he's an all time great by any means. Good fighter though.

[Frozen Butter]

K.O's Don't label you glass chinnded Knockdowns do, Castillo knocked him down twice before chico won and Mayweather knocked chico down 5 times.

bump boofy the... (damn i can't think of a parody for buffy the body) whered did you go.

you never answered.

WAR GUZMAN!!

[Frozen Butter]

I don't think i have seen any margarito nuthuggers in this thread yet.

[Boofdatruth]

Oh c'mon you kidding me. JLC didn't do that. Notice that Chico fought Mayweather the same way he fought Freitas thats a FACT you gotta admit. JLC never depended on his POWER to a POINT where he'd just wait to land a good punch. He'd try and win rounds. Chico on the other hand was GREAT using that style and till this day I can't believe he made it FAR doing so. Trust me I ain't dissing Chico cuz in my opinion he'd beat any 130-135 pounder right now and so would JLC.

I can't change your opinion on how to look at Chico's style. You think he waited for one punch, I don't, and if he did, so what anyway Dom. How you fight at the professional level is how you fight. Chico fought everyone the same way, not just Floyd and Freitas. He just couldn't catch up to Floyd. When both fighters made weight, Chico beat Castillo. Castillo did beat Chico, but Castillo didn't make weight. I didn't like Chico getting on JLC for not making weight because he had the same problem too.

[Silencers]

Not an ATG but he was a very good fighter in his prime.

[Boofdatruth]

bump boofy the... (damn i can't think of a parody for buffy the body) whered did you go.

you never answered.

WAR GUZMAN!!

Because they fought each other. How they did against Floyd doesn't matter because they both lost. One guys Daddy stopped it, and the other used low blows, holding and hitting, and ineffective aggression to make some think he won...even though he lost by 4points on 2 cards and 5 on the other.

[theboymartay]

at 135 he had some very memorable fights but I dont think he is ATG