Jose Luis Castillo an ATG?

[Boofdatruth]

He'll be remembered great for his time but amongst the best from any era, no.

He will be remember as a tough fighter. I don't know if he was great, but he did beat a pfp entrant in Stevie Johnston, and was ranked pfp when he fought Floyd, and he beat some good guys before weight became an issue. One poster failed to realize this lol. I had to smash his thoughts too lol.

[JAB5239]

This isn't a boxing opinion lol.

No, you decided to leave that part of my post out. Wonder why?

You can't be talking about biased lol.

I just call it the way I see it it. You, you're the king of hypocrisi and being biased. I proven that countless times.

Just look at what you wrote lol.

What did I write?

And dude, "quick reply" always works, you aren't on the aol boxing message boards.

What was that? Were you saying something? Did you want to make that ban bet?

[Boofdatruth]

What was that? Were you saying something? Did you want to make that ban bet?

Floyd beat Castillo twice, and look how you quoted my post lol.................Hahahahahahhahahahaha...lol.

[JAB5239]

lol, you are the master of bias lol. You might fool some of the people here trying to fit in lol. Floyd won by 4 and 5 points, and those are facts. Punch stats are opinion.

Sorry boy, it was a gift. Just live with it. Your boy Got the W, just be happy. Real boxing fans, ones that are objective, know it was a gift though.

[Dan...]

Someone made a good point re Mayweather-Castillo the other day - it doesn't matter if you win a round by a little or a lot, its still one round. Castillo lost the first 5 rounds IMO, Floyd was landing far more clean effective punches. JLC really got going in the second half of the fight but IMO just failed to pull it out. I re-watched the fight again very recently and scored it 115-113 to Mayweather but I could live with a draw.

[Boofdatruth]

Someone made a good point re Mayweather-Castillo the other day - it doesn't matter if you win a round by a little or a lot, its still one round. Castillo lost the first 5 rounds IMO, Floyd was landing far more clean effective punches. JLC really got going in the second half of the fight but IMO just failed to pull it out. I re-watched the fight again very recently and scored it 115-113 to Mayweather but I could live with a draw.

Did you think Castillo won or deserved the win?

[Boofdatruth]

Sorry boy, it was a gift. Just live with it. Your boy Got the W, just be happy. Real boxing fans, ones that are objective, know it was a gift though.

Did Floyd deserve to win the first fight just as much as Castillo? Did Dlh beat Pea?

[Dan...]

Did you think Castillo won or deserved the win?

I don't understand the question. Did you read my post? I said I re-watched it the other night and scored it to Mayweather 115-113. Obviously I didn't think he won.

On whether he deserved to win I would again have to say no. Although he pressed the action for most of the fight and was aggressive throughout he only landed any effective punches in very short spurts. There was large periods of several of the rounds where Mayweather was moving effectively, using his defensive abilities to make Castillo miss and scoring well himself, particularly with jabs and quick counter right hands. Castillo did not have enough of those very good rounds to win a decision I don't think.

[JAB5239]

[QUOTE=Boof*******;4012494]

Did

Floyd

deserve

to

win

the

first

fight

just

as

much

as

Castillo?

Did

Dlh

beat

Pea?[/

QUOTE]

Lmao!!!

[Boofdatruth]

I don't understand the question. Did you read my post? I said I re-watched it the other night and scored it to Mayweather 115-113. Obviously I didn't think he won.

On whether he deserved to win I would again have to say no. Although he pressed the action for most of the fight and was aggressive throughout he only landed any effective punches in very short spurts. There was large periods of several of the rounds where Mayweather was moving effectively, using his defensive abilities to make Castillo miss and scoring well himself, particularly with jabs and quick counter right hands. Castillo did not have enough of those very good rounds to win a decision I don't think.

Thank you. I only wanted to know if Castillo deserved the win. I wasn't trying to undermine you, or your thoughts on the fight. I did read your post. You know what effective aggression is.