BoxingScene.com's Top-Ten Pound-For-Pound

[tredh]

Looking at that list and thinking about the fighters on it that I have seen fight boxing's quality has gone down very far.

[TheGreatAli]

Sorry no offense but I was looking for an answer from someone that doesn't have Joe Calzaghe in there name. I have learned no matter what you say with these "type" of people, EVERYONE is wrong and they are right. Its sad and its old.

You can't discuss it with someone on the other side of the coin?

As far as resume goes...

Hopkins > Cotto
Eubank > Clottey
Kessler > Cintron
Lacy > Lujan

[WESS]

It's a lot better than the Ring Magazine list that has one of their owners (Hopkins) ridiculously rated at #4 despite being 2-3 over the last few years. Cotto got KO'd cleanly, he can earn his way back on the list.

True, HOP shouldn't be 4. I think he should be at least 9 or 10 though. That's just me.... BUT Cotto I definitely think he should be placed STILL 5 or 6 and POSSIBLY above MARG. But to be fair I place him right below at 6. Cotto doesn't deserve to be knocked off IMO.

[Kris Silver]

Cotto should not be off the list for one good loss.

Margarito should not be so high so suddenly for one close win.

Hopkins should not be off the list alltogether.

Paul Williams certainly doesn't deserve to be so high after one big win.

The rankings are fluctuating far too much in too short a spaces of time.

[WESS]

*******************************************

i agree for the most part, i just don't see how margarito's win over cotto vaults him all the way up to 5.................from not being on the list at all.

to me, and i guess this must be where im wrong, but winning 1 big fight shouldn't automatically ascend you up a p4p ladder, maybe a diviosional ladder.......................

margo has 5 losses, he beat cintron twice, who was never anywhere near a p4p list, lost to pw, but beat cotto who was ranked, and now he's a top 5 fighter in the world???

**** makes no sense to me..............

True, but I think Cotto deserves to be on the list and since Marg beat him I put him right above Cotto. Its a big jump but I think its only fair. Either way its just my opinion. Where would you place Marg and Cotto?

[affliction55]

pound for pound?

ok there is no way Calzaghe should be in the top 10 he should have never won against hopkins. the man is a joke there is no power behind his punch they are just baby taps.thats the problem with boxing anymore.also arthur abrham is not on his way into the top 10 he is to big of a joke to fight a real fighter.jermain taylor should be on his way back in he fought 2 great fights against pavlik and if anything it should have made his stock rise even with the loses!!!

[Live Dog]

Cotto should not be off the list for one good loss.

Margarito should not be so high so suddenly for one close win.

Hopkins should not be off the list alltogether.

Paul Williams certainly doesn't deserve to be so high after one big win.

The rankings are fluctuating far too much in too short a spaces of time.

[Pullcounter]

1 loss and Cotto drops off the list?

yes and margarito shouldn't be up that high.

[CottoOverrated1]

BOXINGSCENE ERROR! BOXINGSCENE ERROR! BOXINGSCENE ERROR!
BOXINGSCENE ERROR! BOXINGSCENE ERROR! BOXINGSCENE ERROR!

Paul Williams is not! 2-1 with Quintanna, he is 1-1.

thats true. Oh and he is also 1-0 against Margarito. Dont forget about that.

[slicksouthpaw16]

Here is my list:

1)Manny Pacquiao
2)Joe Calzaghe
3)Isreal Vazquez
4)Juan Manuel Marquez
5)Antonio Margrito
6)Miguel Cotto
7)Rafeal Marquez
8)Kelly Pavlik
9)Ivan Calderon
10)Cristian Mijares

Thats more closer to what i was thinking and its a good list. Although, Margarito would comimg in at around 8 on my list and Hopkins would be at 5.