Who should be ranked higher? Floyd or Jones Jr.?

[ELPacman]

Just curious based on who they've beaten and how dominant they were. I mean Floyd hasn't lost, but he's picked most of his opponents as had Jones. Funny how the top P4P seem to pick their opponents strategically. Floyd beats an undefeated Englishman who was fighting at an improper weight class, and Jones Jr. fights John Ruiz, a bull**** heavy. Could you imagine Jones in with a Wladimir heavy? I think he woulda been decapitated by the first right hand bomb Wlad lands. So out of the 2? Who should be ranked higher in the history books? Are we gonna forget all about Jones great performances in the past just because he has some losses now and isn't anywhere in the upper echelon he used to be? Or should we let that little wanker be at the top spot because of his strategic wins?

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Mayweather left too much out there when he retired. I say Jones by far.

[Left Hook Tua]

floyd might be a bit more polished but roy was more talented.

roy was better than floyd.

[Dan...]

Roy Jones by far and its not even close TBH. Roy's achievements and resume is just a class above Floyd's at this stage. Floyd would have to come back and totally clean out 147 to even compare I think. I have Roy in my top 10 all time p4p whilst Floyd is borderline top 20.

[Jknows]

Roy takes this one..Roy take alot of chances in boxing took dangerous fights for him..and went up and down in his weight winning fights...Roy skill level was tremendous and still has that movement in him he has to be one of or the most althetic person in boxing..

[RichCCFC]

Roy Jones and it's not even close.

[Da Porno Rican]

Jones of course!

[GTL]

Mayweather wants to be like Jones..

In every way.. Its hard to live up to a fighter thats better than you..

Jones Jr. is the best fighter I've ever watched and I'm honored that it was in my era..

He DOMINATED all his opponents..

MMay, sweaks by in his biggest wins (DLH, Castillo)

[mspiegelo]

wow. i picked jones jr. but that doesn't mean i agree with calling the most talented boxer of the next generation a fraud...

[Dan...]

Mayweather wants to be like Jones..

In every way.. Its hard to live up to a fighter thats better than you..

Jones Jr. is the best fighter I've ever watched and I'm honored that it was in my era..

He DOMINATED all his opponents..

MMay, sweaks by in his biggest wins (DLH, Castillo)

I love Roy as much as anyone but I'm thinking you may need to qualify this statement a little. But yeah, Roy is the best I've ever seen. Prime Roy did not lose rounds for fight after fight.