Who won DLH-Whitaker?

[Thread Stealer]

it was @ 140lbs, whitaker was not shot yet

It was @ 147. Whitaker had been @ 147 and above since 1993.

[Dynamite Kid]

are you blind, please erase your post and you will be forgiven

why was Oscar robbed ?

it was not a close fight ?

[Dynamite Kid]

I was probably just bull****ting or trolling then. I had DLH beating Tito 6-5-1. DLH rounds 2, 3, 5-7, 9. Tito rounds 4, 8, 10-12. Round 1 even.

I had DLH winning the rematch narrowly over Balco Mosley.

Quartey and Sturm, those are other stories.

i agree with this sounds a lot more reallistic version of events of Oscar v Tito allthough i scored it a draw

i had Oscar beating Shane second time

but i thought he lost to Quartey and Sturm

[-Hyperion-]

It was @ 147. Whitaker had been @ 147 and above since 1993.

yep.....and he was ranked 1 or 2 in most p4p rankings before fighting Oscar....

[Slotff]

I have watched that fight like a gajillion times and probably scored it a good 7 or 8 times. I have had it wide for de la Hoya, wide for Whitaker, close for both guys and a draw. It really depends on what you watch specifically for each time. I feel though, in my heart, that de la Hoya won it closely.

[Thread Stealer]

yep.....and he was ranked 1 or 2 in most p4p rankings before fighting Oscar....

The Ring had it like this at the end of 1996:

1996

1. Roy Jones Jr.
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Pernell Whitaker
4. Felix Trinidad
5. Ricardo Lopez
6. Junior Jones
7. Kostya Tszyu
8. Terry Norris
9. Evander Holyfield
10. Mark Johnson

I don't know what it was exactly before Whitaker-DLH. Jones had been DQ'd against Griffin and Whitaker struggled pretty bad against Hurtado.

There might've been some slight changes but I doubt they dropped Whitaker that much despite the tough bout.

[MASSMAN]

SweetPea Won that fight

Ring Generalship won this fight for Sweetpea. He made Oscar look lost and amatuerish. The Hopkins/Calzaghe fight was kind of similiar. Sweetpea got the early knockdown, Hopkins got the early knockdown against Calzaghe as well, but lost on the scorecards.

[Dynamite Kid]

Ring Generalship won this fight for Sweetpea. He made Oscar look lost and amatuerish. The Hopkins/Calzaghe fight was kind of similiar. Sweetpea got the early knockdown, Hopkins got the early knockdown against Calzaghe as well, but lost on the scorecards.

but he did'nt did he when u use ring generalship u have to make it clear to the judges what u are doing Whitaker fought like he did'nt wanna lose but not like he wanted to win

a good example of ring generalship is how Griffin beat Toney

[oldgringo]

The Ring had it like this at the end of 1996:

1996

1. Roy Jones Jr.
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Pernell Whitaker
4. Felix Trinidad
5. Ricardo Lopez
6. Junior Jones
7. Kostya Tszyu
8. Terry Norris
9. Evander Holyfield
10. Mark Johnson

I don't know what it was exactly before Whitaker-DLH. Jones had been DQ'd against Griffin and Whitaker struggled pretty bad against Hurtado.

There might've been some slight changes but I doubt they dropped Whitaker that much despite the tough bout.

He also struggled with Rivera in two fights, and had been abusing drugs and alcohol well before the De La Hoya fight. He was a faded fighter, but a tough test all the same.

[Sithis]

that many people think oscar won?

wow.