Who's higher on your ATG list, Mayweather or Whitaker?

[Xplosivo]

Because he beat better competition at every phase of his career.

He was fighting championship level competition inside of 12 fights.

Mayweather > Vargas
Ramirez > Manfredy
Haugen > Gatti
Nelson > Corrales
Pendleton > Augustus
Paez > Chavez
Superstar > Castillo
McGirt > Judah
Vazquez > Baldomir

and so on and so forth.

Funny you put it that way, isn't it?

Vargas? Manfredy? Gatti? Augustus? Baldomir?

LMFAO Those are not even Mayweather's top 7 wins

Corrales, Castillo, De La Hoya, Hernandez, Chavez, Judah, Hatton, AND whats the funniest thing is your putting whitakers best opponents versus mayweather's worse to compare them, man your biased as hell when it comes to pernell whitaker, im done here.

[oldgringo]

I can't decide whether this is sad or funny.

both. it's like looking at a ******ed kid playing basketball. you laugh a little at first until you see he's mentally challenged, then it's just sad.

[Parody]

Mayweather = 39 wins 0 losses

Whitaker = 40 wins 4 losses (1 by Stoppage) and 1 draw.

Mayweather's Top 7 wins:

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Zab Judah
Jesus Chavez


Losses:

0

Whitaker's Top 7 wins:


Azumah Nelson
Buddy McGirt
Julio Cesar Vasquez
Jose Luis Ramirez
Jorge Paez
Roger Mayweather
Greg Haugen

Losses:

Jose Luis Ramirez
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Carlos Bojorquez

Mayweather's titles:

130 (Linear)
135 (Linear)
140 (Hatton was the King)
147 (Linear)
154

6 Time World champion in 5 Different weight classes.

Whitaker's titles:

135 (Linear)
140
147 (Linear)
154

4 time world champion at 4 Different weight classes.

Pretty much settles everything.

[SmarterChild]

A lot of people are voting for Pernell simply because their loyd haters, or just plain ******

[Parody]

all I got from that was that you think that Maweather is better because he doesnt have the losses Whitaker did, despite the fact that the 1st fight with Ramirez was a robbery and Whitaker was on ******* for all his other losses.

Or maybe he was trying to imply Mayweather had more linear titles at more weight classes + Undefeated + Had some names in his resume?

[IMDAZED]

I'm starting to feel sad.

A lot of these youngsters (and I'm only 28!) don't have history of the sport and don't really care. They just latch on to one fighter. Look, it's cool and all to love a fighter but you gotta be objective man.

It doesn't matter if Floyd Mayweather is undefeated or not. It's about who he beat. And Floyd Mayweather hasn't beaten anyone near the guys Whitaker beat. Seriously.

Sad...

[Vasyl’s dad]

A lot of people are voting for Pernell simply because their loyd haters, or just plain ******

Or Pernell simply fought better competition, wasn't afraid of any matchup and didn't use excuses not to fight someone.

In the end, Pernells place in history amongst the greats will never be questioned.

Floyds already is.

[IMDAZED]

Or maybe he was trying to imply Mayweather had more linear titles at more weight classes + Undefeated + Had some names in his resume?

Linear titles? Outside of 130 and 135 (and not EVEN 135!) Floyd hasn't won ANY linear title. But if you wann agree with Explosivo's "pretend" titles then yeah, Floyd has won linear titles.

Undefeated? Sure. He also retired at 32. At that same age, Whitaker had one loss - a disgusting robbery to Jose Luis Ramirez that he easily avenged.

Had some names on his resume? Nowhere near as good as Whitaker's and plenty of people (myself included) have already proven this.

So...maybe he's just a blind fan who can't even be objective just once?

[SmarterChild]

I'm starting to feel sad.

A lot of these youngsters (and I'm only 28!) don't have history of the sport and don't really care. They just latch on to one fighter. Look, it's cool and all to love a fighter but you gotta be objective man.

It doesn't matter if Floyd Mayweather is undefeated or not. It's about who he beat. And Floyd Mayweather hasn't beaten anyone near the guys Whitaker beat. Seriously.

Sad...

Ever heard the word "achievements"
you either really hate Floyd or are sucking the sweet Pea

and skill wise, don't even go there

[Burner]

Or Pernell simply fought better competition, wasn't afraid of any matchup and didn't use excuses not to fight someone.

In the end, Pernells place in history amongst the greats will never be questioned.

Floyds already is.

Do you ever make a post thats not about Mayweather ducking someone...god thats old..the man is retired *** 'em.