Who's higher on your ATG list, Mayweather or Whitaker?

[oldgringo]

Care to explain why Whitaker is better?

Because he beat better competition at every phase of his career.

He was fighting championship level competition inside of 12 fights.

Mayweather > Vargas
Ramirez > Manfredy
Haugen > Gatti
Nelson > Corrales
Pendleton > Augustus
Paez > Chavez
Superstar > Castillo
McGirt > Judah
Vazquez > Baldomir

and so on and so forth.

[Sweet Pea 50]

Is it any surprise who I voted for?
But really, I still don't think Mayweather isn't "really" retired. So he might have future chances to surpass Pea. Only time can tell...

[Steak]

LOL @ BOLD, im not even going to say anything at all as your just trying to bait posters.

chavez-whitaker on paper will always be a draw even though most had whitaker winning including me, mayweather beat castillo twice.

What is Azumah Nelson's best win again?

honestly, have you seen Julio Cesar Vasquez?

http://youtube.com/watch?v=3Z0Mg-dw16o

this guy was no slouch, even if he didnt have a big name. He was a better fighter than an old version of De La Hoya.

Julio Cesar Chavez is much better than Castillo, and there is no doubt about that. Whitaker beat him 116-112, which is about what Mayweather beat Castillo by in the rematch.

Azuhah Nelson is a HOF fighter who gave hell to a prime Salvador Sanchez, ruled 130lbs for years, and has wins over guys like Jeff Fenech and Bazooka Gomez.

[oldgringo]

LOL @ BOLD, im not even going to say anything at all as your just trying to bait posters.

chavez-whitaker on paper will always be a draw even though most had whitaker winning including me, mayweather beat castillo twice.

What is Azumah Nelson's best win again?

Jeff Fenech, Bazooka Gomez, Mario Martinez, Juan LaPorte, Gabriel Reulas

don't be ******.

[Scott9945]

floyd by a mile

I can't decide whether this is sad or funny.

[Xplosivo]

Mayweather = 39 wins 0 losses

Whitaker = 40 wins 4 losses (1 by Stoppage) and 1 draw.

Mayweather's Top 7 wins:

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Zab Judah
Jesus Chavez


Losses:

0

Whitaker's Top 7 wins:


Azumah Nelson
Buddy McGirt
Julio Cesar Vasquez
Jose Luis Ramirez
Jorge Paez
Roger Mayweather
Greg Haugen

Losses:

Jose Luis Ramirez
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Carlos Bojorquez

Mayweather's titles:

130 (Linear)
135 (Linear)
140 (Hatton was the King)
147 (Linear)
154

6 Time World champion in 5 Different weight classes.

Whitaker's titles:

135 (Linear)
140
147 (Linear)
154

4 time world champion at 4 Different weight classes.

[Xplosivo]

Jeff Fenech, Bazooka Gomez, Mario Martinez, Juan LaPorte, Gabriel Reulas

don't be ******.

[IMDAZED]

Mayweather = 39 wins 0 losses
Whitaker = 40 wins 4 losses (1 by Stoppage) and 1 draw.

Mayweather's Top 7 wins:

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Zab Judah
Jesus Chavez


Losses:

0

Whitaker's Top 7 wins:


Azumah Nelson
Buddy McGirt
Julio Cesar Vasquez
Jose Luis Ramirez
Jorge Paez
Roger Mayweather
Greg Haugen

Losses:

Jose Luis Ramirez
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Carlos Bojorquez

Mayweather's titles:

130 (Linear)
135 (Linear)
140 (Hatton was the King)
147 (Linear)
154

6 Time World champion in 5 Different weight classes.

Whitaker's titles:

135 (Linear)
140
147 (Linear)
154

LMAO @ this. Linear? Hahahahahaha

Hatton was the king of 140? When did Mayweather fight him there??

Wow...thank God there are other posters to see this post. They wouldn't believe it if I told them.

[Steak]

Mayweather = 39 wins 0 losses

Whitaker = 40 wins 4 losses (1 by Stoppage) and 1 draw.

Mayweather's Top 7 wins:

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Zab Judah
Jesus Chavez


Losses:

0

Whitaker's Top 7 wins:


Azumah Nelson
Buddy McGirt
Julio Cesar Vasquez
Jose Luis Ramirez
Jorge Paez
Roger Mayweather
Greg Haugen

Losses:

Jose Luis Ramirez
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Carlos Bojorquez

Mayweather's titles:

130 (Linear)
135 (Linear)
140 (Hatton was the King)
147 (Linear)
154

6 Time World champion in 5 Different weight classes.

Whitaker's titles:

135 (Linear)
140
147 (Linear)
154

4 time world champion at 4 Different weight classes.

all I got from that was that you think that Maweather is better because he doesnt have the losses Whitaker did, despite the fact that the 1st fight with Ramirez was a robbery and Whitaker was on ******* for all his other losses.

[Dorian]

mayweather = 39 Wins 0 Losses

Whitaker = 40 Wins 4 Losses (1 By Stoppage) And 1 Draw.

Mayweather's Top 7 Wins:

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Zab Judah
Jesus Chavez


Losses:

0

Whitaker's Top 7 Wins:


Azumah Nelson
Buddy Mcgirt
Julio Cesar Vasquez
Jose Luis Ramirez
Jorge Paez
Roger Mayweather
Greg Haugen

Losses:

Jose Luis Ramirez
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Carlos Bojorquez

Mayweather's Titles:

130 (linear)
135 (linear)
140 (hatton Was The King)
147 (linear)
154

6 Time World Champion In 5 Different Weight Classes.

Whitaker's Titles:

135 (linear)
140
147 (linear)
154

4 Time World Champion At 4 Different Weight Classes.

end Of Thread