Who's higher on your ATG list, Mayweather or Whitaker?

[Dorian]

Floyd Mayweather easy

[warp1432]

Floyd Mayweather easy

Care to explain why that is?

[Dan...]

Whitaker, but it is quite close.

[IMDAZED]

Care to explain why that is?

Just ignore those kind of responses, man. If he could explain it, he would. But now we're gonna get some kid who probably has only seen clips of Whitaker spout off Mayweather stats and his graceful moves in the ring...

Look man, I've been a fan of Floyd since 96 but this comparison is just...nuts.

[Xplosivo]

Care to explain why that is?

Care to explain why Whitaker is better?

[MayweatherJr.]

Whitaker, but it is quite close.

Sweet pea was a great defensive fighter while fFoyd's the complete package. It's Floyd w/o a dout.

[Steak]

Azumeh Nelson>Corrales
Julio Cesar Chavez>Castillo
Julio Cesar Vasquez>Oscar De La Hoya
Buddy McGirt>Anyone at 140 and 147 that Mayweather beat

well...that about covers the comparison of their best wins.

[Xplosivo]

Azumeh Nelson>Corrales
Julio Cesar Chavez>Castillo
Julio Cesar Vasquez>Oscar De La Hoya
Buddy McGirt>Anyone at 140 and 147 that Mayweather beat

well...that about covers the comparison of their best wins.

LOL @ BOLD, im not even going to say anything at all as your just trying to bait posters.

chavez-whitaker on paper will always be a draw even though most had whitaker winning including me, mayweather beat castillo twice.

What is Azumah Nelson's best win again?

[Motofan]

Sweet Pea. He fought and beat better opposition then Floyd. Floyd might have been better, but you cant give him credit for what he could have done but didnt.

[IMDAZED]

LOL @ BOLD, im not even going to say anything at all as your just trying to bait posters.

chavez-whitaker on paper will always be a draw even though most had whitaker winning including me, mayweather beat castillo twice.

What is Azumah Nelson's best win again?

First of all, Julio Cesar Vssquez in his prime at 154 is BETTER than an aging Oscar De La Hoya at 154 which is his, what, fifth division? Vasquez was the same guy who dropped Winky Wright five times.

Umm, whether its on paper or nor, Whitaker-Chavez was a huge robbery and a big win for Pea. PLUS...why are you comparing Mayweather-Castillo to that? Castillo wasn't a third of the fighter Julio Cesar Chavez was.

And your last question tells me you know absolutely NOTHING about Azumah Nelson and probably have never seen him fight. Nelson is one of the best fighters of the past 25 years - a first ballot Hall of Famer whose best win COULD be his incredible 8th round TKO over three-division champ and undefeated Jeff Fenech in Fenech's backyard of Australia. When most thought he was washed up. And there are plenty of other solid wins on this ALL-TIME GREAT'S resume.

Please.