How is Joe Beating Pavlik at 168 or 175, a HUGE deal?!?

[Sir_Joe]

Yeah, 6'0" is so small

5'10 1/2, smaller than Margarito, Williams etc.

[Tony628]

bernard is 43... of course its a big win... and also was a MW his entire career... its slightly different...

and youve got it backwards... calzaghe beating bernard isnt a BIG win..... stilll a good win.... but because bernard is 43 and fought at MW his whole career... its not as HUGE


this isnt a diss towards calzaghe... yall are getting to defensive... im not dissing calzaghe... im simply saying... kelly fights 2 classes below where joe fights no...

so are you saying mayweather's win over hatton wasn't a big deal because hatton was two weight classes below floyd?

[THE REED]

Joe Calzaghe is a SMW, Pavlik is a MW. Calzaghe isn't a legit Light Heavy after 1 fight...

If Wladimir Klitschko KOs Haye will it be a big deal? Of course!

no, no not really lol... everyone will say he wasnt big enough to be in there with wlad...

if i remember correctly joe cant make 168 anymore, which would make himmmmmmm???????'


you get to defensive on joe, this isnt a diss to joe, or a discredit to him... im simply saying... pavlik willl be blown up and fighting at a weight he hasnt ever fought at...

[C'MONMANG']

Pavlik fights at 160... how would joe beating him at 168 or 175 be such a HUGE win?

if Joe shrunk down to 160 and beat him, then Id say WOW...

ofcourse you dont think its a big deal.

listen Pal. Both JT AND MIRANDA were big middles

JT is gonna fight 168 and I believe Miranda is as well. ( not sure about the Abraham rematch tho )

point is Kel is PRIME and a BIG MIDDLE. hasnt had a crappy showing yet.

educate yourself

[abadger]

a win over kelly would mean more than a win over roy at this stage


hows that...

Nice. I knew you didn't mean it really

[VERSION1 (V1)]

So if Bernard Hopkins beat Calzaghe it wouldn't be considered a big win?

It would have been a nice win but not big

[THE REED]

so are you saying mayweather's win over hatton wasn't a big deal because hatton was two weight classes below floyd?

he wasnt two weight classes below, he was one... and a lot of posters on here would have you believe it WASNT because he didnt fight someone his own size... The knockout was surprising to me though...

[Sir_Joe]

You also picked Pavlik to win this fight so it obviously must mean something, no matter what you say here... you are trying to start **** because he's not fighting Roy.

.....

[THE REED]

ofcourse you dont think its a big deal.

listen Pal. Both JT AND MIRANDA were big middles

JT is gonna fight 168 and I believe Miranda is as well. ( not sure about the Abraham rematch tho )

point is Kel is PRIME and a BIG MIDDLE. hasnt had a crappy showing yet.

educate yourself

would you like to continue posting in here?

[johnm is...]

so are you saying mayweather's win over hatton wasn't a big deal because hatton was two weight classes below floyd?

Props for finding a picture of the only punch Hatton landed in that fight.