How is Joe Beating Pavlik at 168 or 175, a HUGE deal?!?

[Sir_Joe]

So if Bernard Hopkins beat Calzaghe it wouldn't be considered a big win?

[Nacho_Analstain]

Pavlik could make 168 easily and it not hurt his performance, If Calzaghe went to 160 there would be one of two outcomes .. A) Joe is weight drained as ****.
B) Hes even faster and wins easier

[Xyei]

It would be a good win but not a Huge win! Pavlik is a young, undefeated guy. I would like to see the fight in hopes that Pavlik would win but I think Joe would win a UD. It would indeed be a Huge win for Pavlik if he could pull it off.

[THE REED]

So if Bernard Hopkins beat Calzaghe it wouldn't be considered a bit win?

bernard is 43... of course its a big win... and also was a MW his entire career... its slightly different...

and youve got it backwards... calzaghe beating bernard isnt a BIG win..... stilll a good win.... but because bernard is 43 and fought at MW his whole career... its not as HUGE


this isnt a diss towards calzaghe... yall are getting to defensive... im not dissing calzaghe... im simply saying... kelly fights 2 classes below where joe fights no...

[abadger]

Americans trying to discredit Joe already...tut tut.

[hunter010]

jones would be a better fight for cal...

[Sir_Joe]

bernard is 43... of course its a big win... and also was a MW his entire career... its slightly different...

and youve got it backwards... calzaghe beating bernard isnt a BIG win..... stilll a good win.... but because bernard is 43 and fought at MW his whole career... its not as HUGE


this isnt a diss towards calzaghe... yall are getting to defensive... im not dissing calzaghe... im simply saying... kelly fights 2 classes below where joe fights no...

Joe Calzaghe is a SMW, Pavlik is a MW. Calzaghe isn't a legit Light Heavy after 1 fight...

If Wladimir Klitschko KOs Haye will it be a big deal? Of course!

[THE REED]

Americans trying to discredit Joe already...tut tut.

a win over kelly would mean more than a win over roy at this stage


hows that...

[ИATAS]

Trinidad was a puny LMW.

Yeah, 6'0" is so small

[Sir_Joe]

bernard is 43... of course its a big win... and also was a MW his entire career... its slightly different...

and youve got it backwards... calzaghe beating bernard isnt a BIG win..... stilll a good win.... but because bernard is 43 and fought at MW his whole career... its not as HUGE


this isnt a diss towards calzaghe... yall are getting to defensive... im not dissing calzaghe... im simply saying... kelly fights 2 classes below where joe fights no...

You also picked Pavlik to win this fight so it obviously must mean something, no matter what you say here... you are trying to start **** because he's not fighting Roy.