Prime Oscar vs Prime Floyd

[frankpaganini]

Floyd beats Oscar at 130 but vice versa at 154 or 147 Floyd was a different beast at 130 he was the complete package and had good powr but now he is more defensive at 154 or 147 and that benefits Oscar if he doesnt gas early

i agree with this...

at 130 floyd beats him.

at 154 and 147 oscar beats him...

if we are talking both in their primes of course.

[warp1432]

I think Floyd beats him at 130 and 135, but Oscar would beat him at 147.

[SupremeElectron]

Floyd at 130 was as close to unbeatable as you can get.

It would take a prime Duran or Leonard as Lightweights to even come close to him.

DLH gets smoked by Lightweight Mayweather. Smoked. I want someone to tell me that the DLH that fought John John Molina comes to close to Floyd.

[MANGLER]

Close call, but i'd go wit DLH. Shane has some similar qualities to PBF and he beat Oscar in 200, but he was takin risks that Floyd never would. Oscar at his best might not have gotten the KO but he woulda won.

[Scott9945]

There are 5 people here who were not old enough to see a prime DLH so they dont know, We forgive them dont we?

Quit with the Oscar the dominant welterweight champion bull****. He barely beat Whitaker and Quartey (and wouldn't give them rematches), ran from Trinidad, and got worked by Mosley. I was old enough to see a prime Ray Leonard and Tommy Hearns, who were both miles better than De La Hoya.

[Motofan]

Ancient, slow, inactive Oscar gave Floyd a tough fight. Prime Oscar destroys Floyd.

[Parody]

Quit with the Oscar the dominant welterweight champion bull****. He barely beat Whitaker and Quartey (and wouldn't give them rematches), ran from Trinidad, and got worked by Mosley. I was old enough to see a prime Ray Leonard and Tommy Hearns, who were both miles better than De La Hoya.

Good post

but Hey you cant blame the guy...Fanboys will vote for Oscar...Oscar is the biggest thing in boxing and Floyd isn't the most liked character in Boxing and specially Boxingscene, Hence people will obviously vote for Oscar over Floyd. In reality Floyd beats him and I agree with most of your post, A prime oscar struggled against a ******* addict out of prime whitaker, Ike Quartey (Quartey won 8 rounds in that fight, easily) and Struggled against Mosley. A Prime Mayweather beats him hands down.

[Parody]

Ancient, slow, inactive Oscar gave Floyd a tough fight. Prime Oscar destroys Floyd.

Just like he destroyed Mosley, Quartey and Trinidad? Two of those fighters who had no defense lol and were talking a defensive genius here who is a better fighter than those.

Oh wait "Those fighters were better than Floyd" LOL I'm waiting to hear this.

[good_looking01]

Under Super feather =PBF
Lightweight above = DLH

Depends whenm you think they were closest to thier primes though...

[The Hammer]

Just like he destroyed Mosley, Quartey and Trinidad? Two of those fighters who had no defense lol and were talking a defensive genius here who is a better fighter than those.

Oh wait "Those fighters were better than Floyd" LOL I'm waiting to hear this.

Stop hugging Mayweather's nuts, Parody. You're embarassing yourself.