Which active fighter has a better legacy than Mayweather?

[RageX]

Oscar
Trinidad
Wright
Tarver

that does enough IMO

You cant use the "Welterweight" excuse on Hopkins because can Trinidad and Wright even make 160 any more? I'm sure Wright can but not Trinidad, and Trinidad couldn't have made Welterweight when he fought Hopkins, their body growed into that weight.

Wright ranked P4P #2 when Hopkins beat him, Tarver ranked P4P #9.

Bernard himself has been P4P #1 for some time, with 20 title defenses.

AND HES DOING EVERYTHING NOW AT THE AGE OF ****ING 43, CONSIDER THAT BITCHES!

[Ryn0]

RJJ, Hopkins, Calzaghe but they've been champions way longer. Pac-man may have a claim if he beat JMM cause he beat two ATG in Barrera and Morales. Holyfield ofcourse ermmm that all i can think of but Oscar De La Hoya maybe and if you include him then Trinidad may be included but they are nearing the end of there careers mayweather has a solid few years left.

[RageX]

RJJ, Hopkins, Calzaghe but they've been champions way longer. Pac-man may have a claim if he beat JMM cause he beat two ATG in Barrera and Morales. Holyfield ofcourse ermmm that all i can think of but Oscar De La Hoya maybe and if you include him then Trinidad may be included but they are nearing the end of there careers mayweather has a solid few years left.

If Mayweather beats DLH again and then beats Miguel Cotto then ill have him ahead.

[ElGranLuchador]

Reggie Strickland has fought quite a few big names too.

He won almost as many big fights as De La Hoya.

It is true that Oscar never ducked anyone, but really, he only beat Quartey and Vargas.

There are fights that could have gone the other way, on both sides, but still, he only winds up with 2 or 3 legit victories.

oscar defeated tito and mosley in their 2nd fight plus his titles are more than mayweather´s

[Fox McCloud]

oscar defeated tito and mosley in their 2nd fight plus his titles are more than mayweather´s

I guess... if you say he beat Tito and Mosley, I think you have to say that he lost to Sturm and Quartey as well...

Pretty much the same deal in those sets of fights.

That's why I said, one way or another, he ends up with 2 or 3 good wins at best.

[ElGranLuchador]

no one in his right mind thinks he lost to quartey he lost to sturm without a doubt

[ElGranLuchador]

id say jose luis castillo
defeated stevie johnson twice in the upset of the year
knocked out former world champ cesar bazan
defeated floyd mayweather
defeated joel casamayor
knocked out julio diaz
knocked out diego corrales
forgot about maromero paez

[JC Warrior]

Holyfield, Toney, Hopkins, Jones Jr, Oscar, Trinidad, Pacquiao, Calzaghe, and Wlad Klitschko.

I know Wlad's inclusion might raise some questions but he's beaten solid competition in the most important division even if he hasn't always been spectacular doing it.

[MELLY-MEL...]

i think the next few years are going to make floyd into a top 20 atg, or keep him down at 30 and under depending on who, for how long, and how much he fights.

[King Koopa]

Israel Vazquez