Most ridiculous statements you have seen defended on this forum

[napkin]

Saying Adam Hartley isn't dangerous.

[Nacho_Analstain]

That's a damn good question. One I would like to have answered by those who have suggested it as a gameplan for Cotto over Margarito.



Not when you're incredibly easy to hit dancing around on the outside. No.

**** me Addison, You really have no fear of getting Cottowned

[Me La Pelan]

That Pac ain't ducking JMM.... they should have the winner of Diaz Pac fight the winner of Campbell JMM and unify the weight class. Asuming JMM vs Campbell gets made.

[warp1432]

The main problem that I have with the ring is that there are no time restrictions on when to defend it or quality of opponent for that matter.

Eh. I guess, but that was always clear from the start, but it really annoys me when people say that The Ring is now corrupted that Golden Boy is owning it. They haven't done anything to lose that credit yet.

And let's not forget all the **** the other organizations have done (Morrade Hakkar...)

[Addison]

**** me Addison, You really have no fear of getting Cottowned

Nah, only Margarittowned this time.

[Me La Pelan]

What's wrong with that? it's a perfectly reasonable (and true) statement to make.

A conversation took place in the early 90's between Larry Merchant and Angelo Dundee, in which Dundee said Chavez was the toughest fighter he had ever seen. Larry asked him ...tougher than Ali, Leonard, Frazier or Hearns? And Angelo Dundee replied "THE TOUGHEST I"VE EVER SEEN!" So I'm absoulutly positively SURE the Great MR.DUNDEE doesn't know **** according to you right?

[KING •]

Cotto isn't worthy to put on gloves with Floyd.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...2&postcount=62

[Clegg]

oh my, what a list

Felix Trinidad-all he had is left hook, big puncher, no skill whatsoever
Roy Jones Jr
Bernard Hopkins-barely won fights against journey men, never dominated anyone in his weight class, hugely overrated
Floyd Mayweather
Lennox Lewis
Evander Holyfield-this guy got like 10 losses so i don't know how you got him on the list, how many losses does joe have?! that's right, 0
Mike Tyson-crack addict, tested positive for marijuana, got beaten by journey men, has wins over HW which participated in the worst possible era
Larry Holmes-worst era ever
George Foreman
Manny Pacquiao-keeps fighting washed up mexicans
Erik Morales-famous for fighting mexicans that hold these weird titles nobody knows like, ifh, wbs and **** like that
Marco Antonio Barrera-famous for fighting someone like morales, who's pretty much nobody knows
Julio Cesar Chavez-tomato can, got ****ted on when he stepped up in competition like his son, overprotected fighter, hometown fighter
James Toney-LOL!
Juan Manuel Marquez-this guy goes up in competition and loses, can't handle pressure, not champion worthy
Wilfredo Gomez-LOL! who?
Alexis Arguello-who?
Miguel Cotto-LOL! cotto better than calzaghe?! your boxing knowledge is nano-like
Aaron Pryor-overrated flashy fighter
Roberto Duran
Kostya Tsyzu-beaten by an exposed brit
Thomas Hearns
Sugar Ray Leonard
Winky Wright-LOL! lost to vargas who got beat by an overrated ODLH
Shane Mosley-it's not surprising his PPV are garbage, he's overrated
Michael Spinks-good amateur that's it, didn't belong in the pros

i think the appropriate question here is;
Is Calzaghe Top 5 A.T.G? maybe not but he's definitely Top 10!

I also think that Gorilla would've beaten a prime Tyson back in the 80s but Floyd would beat him though. Floyd is too fast and too slick. Floyd by UD.

The one about Floyd beating a gorilla is probably a joke, and yet still it isn't as ****** as the other two comments.

[WetSexyLlamaPR]

I saw someone post something saying that Cotto is too big at 147, it isn't fair to other WW fighters and that he should fight at 154 or 160... WTF I'm going to look for the post.

[WetSexyLlamaPR]

Here it is posted by Horus:

5. Is Miguel Cotto Really WW or a Junior Middle Weight...?

We all know that Miguel Cotto drains himself to make weight for the welther weight division....he has been doing this for years he even did it at 140, when He entered the ring weighing 157-pounds, making him a Jr. Middleweight defending his Jr. Welterweight Title over his 140-pound challenger, DeMarcus Corley.

So the real question is why havent Miguel Cotto move up to his Natural Weight Class....

Which is Junior Middle Weight or Middle Weight..Instead of Draining Himself 20 pounds for every fight...?

you have to wonder how he'd fare against contenders who enter the ring weighing 154 or more, like he does all the time.

Cotto needs to move up to at least 154. It cannot be healthy to lose 20 plus pounds for an official weigh-in and then gain almost 20 pounds before stepping between the ropes.

That should not be allowed.
New York Rules do not allow unofficial weigh in to be announce of fight night... (i.e Mosley and Judah Fight No Unofficial Weigh In)

Miguel Cotto should not be fighting at Welther Weight if he is going to enter the ring as a Middle Weight It's just not right. Arguments can be made that Cotto is starving himself to fight at Welter, so he can have an advantage in size and power over smaller men.

I don't understand why he's allowed to show up so far over the weight limit. What ever happened to rules? If a fight is contracted for 140-pounds and you show up 157 (Corley), then you have breeched the contract. Without rules, where's the legitimacy?

Cotto coming up from 140 and making the lightweight limit twice early in his pro career and being a midget 5'7 or 5'8 for the WW division definitely makes him a natural JrMW or even MW. WTF.