Just how great is james toney?

[sterling]

Yea, but then he lost twice to him. The KO put fear into Jones. IMO Jones was always scared of Tarver. Even though Jones is one of my favorite fighters ever, I would always pick Tarver over him.

lol tarver put fear in jones ? :P more like jones put fear in jones i think jones jus doubted himself after the first fight.
Who would be scared of tarver? hes no mike tyson.

[Sweet Pete]

Prime or not, Tarver would beat Jones.

Kill yourself.

[sterling]

Kill yourself.

smartest thing u said all night

[Sweet Pete]

smartest thing u said all night

Then I take you think that post was Einstein-esque.

[phallus]

James Toney is the only man alive that has a legitimate claim that he was better than Roy Jones in his prime.

james toney and roy jones jr are the two most naturally talented fighters i've seen in my lifetime, and a weight drained james toney could still hang with roy. james is "a blown up supermiddlweight " who moved up to hw and beat down and knocked out ATG evander holyfield. if james was as dedicated to being in shape as floyd mayweather we would all be talking today about how james toney is the greatest of all time. end of story