Whos resume is better

[Jim Jeffries]

This post is very unbiased. Congratulations.

Hatton+Castillo+Corrales+Judah >>>>>> Kessler+Lacy+Sheika

Wow, I've never seen a post where you rated Hatton as any higher than a C-level clubfighter. Now, when it benefits Floyd, you have him better than Kessler? And I hope you're not claiming that Oscar and Gatti were not past prime.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Wow, I've never seen a post where you rated Hatton as any higher than a C-level clubfighter. Now, when it benefits Floyd, you have him better than Kessler? And I hope you're not claiming that Oscar and Gatti were not past prime.

I AM RATING THEM AS A CLUSTER. Individually, Hatton is better that Sheika.

I don't know what Oscar is. Past his prime. Before his prime. Whatever. All I know is that Miguel Cotto is excited about fighting Oscar next May. And 45% of the posters on this board picked Oscar to win.

That would be May, 2008. A year after Floyd fought Oscar.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

+Eubank & Veit?

+ Chavez + Famoso + Manfredy.

[Jim Jeffries]

+ Chavez + Famoso + Manfredy.

Sorry, but Eubank is greater than those three combined, by himself.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Sorry, but Eubank is greater than those three combined, by himself.

Remind me again who Eubank fought....

[Jim Jeffries]

I AM RATING THEM AS A CLUSTER. Individually, Hatton is better that Sheika.

I don't know what Oscar is. Past his prime. Before his prime. Whatever. All I know is that Miguel Cotto is excited about fighting Oscar next May. And 45% of the posters on this board picked Oscar to win.

That would be May, 2008. A year after Floyd fought Oscar.

Well, with losses in arguably 4 of his last 5 fights, against 5 different fighters, I would venture to say that a guy listed as one of the top 40 GOAT, might be just slightly past his prime. Oscar was (is??) a hugely popular fighter; giving him a chance, at 35, with only 2 fights in over 3 1/2 years, to beat Cotto at this point, well I can only venture to say that people haven't thought that one all the way through, or perhaps are thinking with their hearts, or just don't like Cotto.

[Jim Jeffries]

Remind me again who Eubank fought....

I guess Benn's a bum too, right? Chris Eubank, you know 2 weight world champ. Defended his middleweight belt 3 times, his SMW belt 14 times. That guy.

[Parody]

This thread is ****ing ridicilous...

[number6]

Floyd, and i dont think its very close.

[Gatti9783]

Why is this a poll? Calzaghe's resume is awful. What a terrible question.