Whos resume is better

[nmuburner22]

I like how Calzaghe has dominated his weight class for so long.Yes Floyd has moved up and down but he hasn't beaten 4 or 5 of the top guys at any single wieght class and standed the test of time like Calzaghe......

lolololololololololololololololo

[RAESAAD]

lolololololololololololololololo

well since you put it that way.....you're probably right heh?

[raysan]

I like how Calzaghe has dominated his weight class for so long.Yes Floyd has moved up and down but he hasn't beaten 4 or 5 of the top guys at any single wieght class and standed the test of time like Calzaghe......

Once you fight the best why not move up and test yourself. Thats like saying, okay i beat the second place guy in a race now let me race the third and fourth place guys to see if i can beat them of course you can, thats dumb. I can see the legacy factor which is impressive for being able to do it so long, but bottom line is anyone with any boxing knowledge is not going to say Joe's resume is better than Floyds.

[RAESAAD]

Once you fight the best why not move up and test yourself. Thats like saying, okay i beat the second place guy in a race now let me race the third and fourth place guys to see if i can beat them of course you can, thats dumb. I can see the legacy factor which is impressive for being able to do it so long, but bottom line is anyone with any boxing knowledge is not going to say Joe's resume is better than Floyds.

It takes a true boxing fan to even bring it up......

[Left2body]

PBF by far, Frank Warren hurt Calz by not getting him the big fights earlier in his career even though he had to have seen the talent. Frank milks his fighters dry then risk them, sad because Calz could've had some excellent fights.

Calz didn't fight a champion or an undefeated fighter till he was 40ish fights into his career and he went against Lacey.

PBF, has Genaro, Castillo (twice), Corrales, DLH, Judah, Hatton, Chavez......its not really close.

[-Swizzy-]

are you ******ed????

I agree, gearsofwar is mentally challenged. The Oscar-Past-His-Prime victory alone is greater than prime kessler and prime lacy put together. Hatton has a shorter reach all of a sudden. c'mon, tyson was 5'10 and fought guys 6-7 inches taller and hatton is only 2 inches shorter than may. PLZ, this thread is nothing more than a mayweather hate thread. I understand that he is annoying I know. But you really gotta make a greater effort than this to demean him.

[The Troll]

You have to count margin of victory as much as who do you actually beat when you do this and to calculate p4p and stuff if you ask me. If you dont Sven Ottke has a better resume than anybody or at least as good. I dont mean to pick on Sven Ottke but you get the idea.

[The Troll]

margin of victory and also important to me is was it a good fight.

[-Hyperion-]

calzaghe has fought the biggest threats, but mayweather has accomplished more.............

[GunStar]

I like how Calzaghe has dominated his weight class for so long.Yes Floyd has moved up and down but he hasn't beaten 4 or 5 of the top guys at any single wieght class and standed the test of time like Calzaghe......

Shut up, n00b! You're an idiot!