Whos resume is better

[TopDawg]

Floyd Mayweather easily.

[Easy-E]

No contest, Floyd has fought 3x the world champions Joe has.

[Technical_Skill]

No contest, Floyd has fought 3x the world champions Joe has.

But Joe beat Evans Ashira with one hand, to me, that gives calzaghe the edge.

[Easy-E]

But Joe beat Evans Ashira with one hand, to me, that gives calzaghe the edge.

True.
He also dominated Jeff Lacy and Peter Manfredo.

[Technical_Skill]

True.
He also dominated Jeff Lacy and Peter Manfredo.

Yeah, personally i had manfredo top 10 p4p at the time, he had the skills to transcend boxing. Calzaghe beating him meant that everyone in america knew who calzaghe was, this was the reason why so many american fight fans couldnt be bothered to watch his biggest fight, even though it was free and on prime time.

And people on this forum will still tell you Calzaghe is a draw in america.

[squealpiggy]

And people on this forum will still tell you Calzaghe is a draw in america.

Joking apart who has told you that and when? It seems utterly absurd to me, which is why it always amused me that Hopkins was always badgering on about fighting Joe at Yankee Stadium. Oh yeah a guy who never brings the crowds versus a guy who noone's ever heard of? Maybe if they just put "JC" on the fight poster then people will think it's the Second Coming of Christ, that could get people to show. Unless they find out that his opponent is Bernard Hopkins...

[Pugilistic™]

mayweather has the better resume

[nmuburner22]

Calzaghe and Gearsofwar an Joe Cal fans got OWNED in this poll....LMAO.

[oldgringo]

I don't know enough about Calzaghes and or Mayweathers resume.

[nmuburner22]

I don't know enough about Calzaghes and or Mayweathers resume.

or Michigan football.