A new Pound-for-Pound List....and it's very good!!

[SUPERBAD23]

List makes no sense and I'll tell you why.

Pacquiao should NOT be above Mayweather.

Hopkins is WAY too high for someone fighting ONCE per year.

Wright at 6???? He should be lower tier.

Calzaghe at 10? A guy undefeated for over a decade is WAY TOO LOW, especially under guys like , Vazquez and Marquez.

Juan Manuel TOO HIGH.

beating contenders and bums from the uk for a decade

[Wiley Hyena]

beating contenders and bums from the uk for a decade

Yeah, but undefeated champ for 10 years! That gets him in. We're not arguing about whether or not he is #1 or #2. But, I have no problem with him being in top ten. He can't be ignored, especially after destroying Lacey like he did.

[SUPERBAD23]

List makes no sense and I'll tell you why.

Pacquiao should NOT be above Mayweather.

Hopkins is WAY too high for someone fighting ONCE per year.

Wright at 6???? He should be lower tier.

Calzaghe at 10? A guy undefeated for over a decade is WAY TOO LOW, especially under guys like Pavlik, Vazquez and Marquez.

Juan Manuel TOO HIGH.

Yeah, but undefeated champ for 10 years! That gets him in. We're not arguing about whether or not he is #1 or #2. But, I have no problem with him being in top ten. He can't be ignored, especially after destroying Lacey like he did.

yeah he should be in the top 10 but not above r.marquez

[BIGPOPPAPUMP]

Let's call it what it is on CalSlappy. The guy has fought NOBODY.

Jermain Taylor is 2-1-1 vs Hopkins, Winky and Pavlik. I would rather be 2-1-1 than 0-0-0 against those guys.

If Calzaghe fought nobody, then Hopkins fought nobody. Hopkins competition during his run was no better if not just as good as the guys who Calzaghe fought.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Yeah, but undefeated champ for 10 years! That gets him in. We're not arguing about whether or not he is #1 or #2. But, I have no problem with him being in top ten. He can't be ignored, especially after destroying Lacey like he did.

Go check the record of Mr. Thomas Damgaard.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

If Calzaghe fought nobody, then Hopkins fought nobody. Hopkins competition during his run was no better if not just as good as the guys who Calzaghe fought.

I'd put a MW Trinidad, Joppy, Eastman, et al above anybody that Slappin' Joe was facing.

And Hopkins went on a Taylor-Taylor-Tarver-Winky run.

Here is the opposition that was available for CalSlappy:

Roy Jones
Bernard Hopkins
Antonio tarver
Winky Wright
Jermain taylor
Glen Johnson
Kelly pavlik
James Toney
etc...

Somehow, Joe couldn't make a single one of those fights happen.

[SUPERBAD23]

Here is the opposition that was available for CalSlappy:

Roy Jones
Bernard Hopkins
Antonio tarver
Winky Wright
Jermain taylor
Glen Johnson
Kelly pavlik
James Toney
etc...

Somehow, Joe couldn't make a single one of those fights happen.[/QUOTE]

My point........

[rambov]

I like the list. Don't agree with everything but its an honest list

[MoneyINC]

''Pacman is chewing up legends and spitting them out at an unbelievable rate.''
Yeah over the hill legends,How pathetic.

Great List! You aint over the hill til your ass is getting KOed every other fight and unable to recite the ABC's

[MickyHatton]

Pavlik has KO'd a top, proven champion. Calzaghe hasn't been anywhere near a guy with Jermain's credentials.

You say that now but its not what was being said by almost all before he completely dominated Lacy.

You way overate Taylor? He closely decisioned a very old Hopkins twice, managed a draw against an ageing Wright and pulled a SD over a blown up Welterweight in Spinks. If he was that good surely he would have dominated these fighters?

Don't get carried away with Pavlik, after all Taylor was probably winning the fight and Pavlik had to get off the floor to win, hes a puncher so......he's not even in Calzaghe's league yet, surely you see that?