Is Hatton the Best Fighter Mayweather Has Ever Faced?

[.Mik.]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

[ianwigley]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

I think it does

[ianwigley]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

Bull****. Name me someone in his divisions(s) who has been better/more dominant.

[ianwigley]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

That don't mean ****. It's just like NME saying The Charlatans are the best band in the world. They're journos - opinions...

[ianwigley]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

Probably because he ain't fought anyone good/credible/in their prime

[msagrain]

should this poll be asked after mayweather loses? the we shall deside?

[Fox McCloud]

should this poll be asked after mayweather loses? the we shall deside?

Should you wait to shoot your mouth off until after the fight?

I deside yes.

[jamesbrown]

currently hatton is his best figther because he hasn't defeated that hugging mother****a plus hatton dreams about pbf so everyday the fight gets closer i am somewhat more worried. Quit hanging, rapping and get your ass to work pbf!

[ianwigley]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

Gatti fought Mayweather, DLH and Micky Ward three times. Those fights are better than anyone Hatton fought. He also came out the other side fresh and ready to fight anyone else.

Hatton? Magee, Maussa (who?), Urango (who?), old Zoo, old JLC.

The irony is thicker than crude oil...

Wise up, dude.

[Fox McCloud]

Doesnt matter who Calzaghe has fought. Your statement was that "there ain't nobody who has dominated their division for so long, unbeaten."

Calzaghe has been the most credible champion in his division (something that Mayweather has not always been in the divisions he's been champion of) for much longer than PBF has. He is also still unbeaten. Your point was incorrect, thats the end of it.

Magee scored a flash knockdown of Ricky Hatton, Hatton still won. You're not even using triangular logic here as Magee and Gatti never fought each other. You're using no logic at all. Shannon Briggs knocked down Lennox Lewis, I guess that means that Samuel Peter would destory Lennox Lewis...THAT is the kind of ******ed logic you're using.

Hatton is on the P4P list. He was Ring fighter of the year. He has been rated top of a division and has won multiple belts. He is also unbeaten. Gatti has barely won any titles, he has barely defended any titles, he has never been considered a top P4P fighter and he has lost 9 times in his career. THAT is why he is not and never was a better fighter than Ricky Hatton.

Gatti was knocked down and beaten by Angel Manfreddy. Thats much more humiliating by being knocked down and defeating Eamonn MaGee. Like I said...your argument is ridiculous.

Shannon Briggs did not knock Lewis down. He wobbled the **** out of him after 4 successive shots to the back of the head, but that was it.