Who Are Your Top 5 Welterweights Now?

[Ace Rockolla]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Shane Mosley
4. Paul Williams
5. Antonio Margarito*

*I agree that Margarito lost the fight on saturday, but I think people are being too quick to disregard him as a top welterweight because of it.

[Guest]

why wouldn't you put cintron up there

Margarito destroyed him and he really hasn't beaten anyone good since then. He has wins over Suarez and now Matthyse. Good fights, but not good wins. I also have Clottey up there because I feel he is a much better fighter than Margarito and Cintron and he would have beaten Margarito if he didn't mess up his hands...

[gixxer]

Williams, Margarito ,moseley,cotto,cintron

[guru]

theres no way i can rate cotto and moes over williams at this point.. williams just beat a top WW and cotto and moes have not...

1 - pbf
2 - williams
3 - cotto
4 - moes
5 - cintron

[oldgringo]

Margarito destroyed him and he really hasn't beaten anyone good since then. He has wins over Suarez and now Matthyse. Good fights, but not good wins. I also have Clottey up there because I feel he is a much better fighter than Margarito and Cintron and he would have beaten Margarito if he didn't mess up his hands...

Do you think Clottey would beat Cintron though? I think that fight is a complete toss up. I tend to judge Clottey by the Gutierrez fight...not by his 4 rounds of glory against Margarito who was coming off a long layoff.

Gutierrez was a young, rugged power puncher who could match Clottey's activity. Clottey struggled with that kid...I think he'd struggle against the sharper, harder puncher in Cintron too.

If anything, that loss to Margarito was a good thing for Cintron. He looks much better now than he did then.

[Kobe Bryant]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Miguel Cotto
3. Shane Mosley
4. Paul Williams
5. Joshua Clottey

I agree with this list.

[P29]

1.PBF
2.Mosley
3.Hatton
4.Cotto
5.Malignaggi

[beauty]

Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley
Zab Judah
Paul Williams

[Double]

Hatton is not a WW

[wolfgang]

Mayweather
cotto
mosley
williams
cintron