Tszyu Was Rated #3 p4p When Hatton Defeated Him

[GunStar]

Casamayor.

Hernandez would've PWNED Casa, Hernandez is one of the greatest 130 pounders of all time, it's a shame not many people knew how great Hernandez was.

[Cletus Funk]

Hernandez would've PWNED Casa, Hernandez is one of the greatest 130 pounders of all time, it's a shame not many people knew how great Hernandez was.

Hernandez at his best maybe. Not the Hernandez who had terrible problems making weight for the Floyd fight. He didn't eat for 3 days before the fight.

[GunStar]

Hernandez at his best maybe. Not the Hernandez who had terrible problems making weight for the Floyd fight. He didn't eat for 3 days before the fight.

Hernandez was not washed up when he fought Floyd, he retired cause he had a life threatening eye injury in his last fight with Floyd, Hernandez at 135 was not the same Hernandez, that's why he lost to Oscar when he moved up to 135 and Oscar was a huge lightweight.

But Hernandez does make many excuses to why he lost to Oscar too, which I never agreed with him, I love Hernandez but he has 1000 reason to why he lost his 2 fights.

Lets not forget Hernandez had 6 title defense after he lost to Oscar at 135.

Most little boxers have a terrible time making weight, most of them kill themselves to make weight, that's part of their life.

[Cletus Funk]

I never said he was washed up, he was just running totally empty. There was an interview with him posted on here in the build up to DLH v PBF. You should have a read of it.

So are you saying you choose to believe Floyd when he said he went into the Castillo fight with a torn rotator cuff (like anyone would do that ) but choose not to believe Hernandez when he gives a detailed breakdown of exactly what he had to go through to make weight for that fight?

Hernandez was not washed up when he fought Floyd, he retired cause he had a life threatening eye injury in his last fight with Floyd, Hernandez at 135 was not the same Hernandez, that's why he lost to Oscar when he moved up to 135 and Oscar was a huge lightweight.

But Hernandez does make many excuses to why he lost to Oscar too, which I never agreed with him, I love Hernandez but he has 1000 reason to why he lost his 2 fights.

Lets not forget Hernandez had 6 title defense after he lost to Oscar at 135.

Most little boxers have a terrible time making weight, most of them kill themselves to make weight, that's part of their life.

[GunStar]

I never said he was washed up, he was just running totally empty. There was an interview with him posted on here in the build up to DLH v PBF. You should have a read of it.

So are you saying you choose to believe Floyd when he said he went into the Castillo fight with a torn rotator cuff (like anyone would do that ) but choose not to believe Hernandez when he gives a detailed breakdown of exactly what he had to go through to make weight for that fight?

It doesn't matter if I believe Floyd or not, I had Floyd winning the Castillo first fight 115-111

[Cletus Funk]

It doesn't matter if I believe Floyd or not, I had Floyd winning the Castillo first fight 115-111

It doesn't matter how you scored the fight, most people had Castillo winning. Even Floyd, which is why he rematched him. So you don't go along with the "Floyd was injured" line for the 1st fight then?

[GunStar]

It doesn't matter how you scored the fight, most people had Castillo winning. Even Floyd which is why he rematched him. So you don't go along with the "Floyd was injured" line for the 1st fight then?

Most people also had Oscar winning his fight against Floyd. When you're hated like the way Floyd is hated, people will say he lost both fights, **** I remember some Floyd haters had Judah winning his fight againt Floyd too.

[Cletus Funk]

You didn't answer my question.

Most people were fairly indifferent to Floyd back then, so don't play the hate card.

Most people also had Oscar winning his fight against Floyd. When you're hated like the way Floyd is hated people will say he lost both fights, **** I remember some Floyd haters had Judah winning his fight againt Floyd.

[GunStar]

You didn't answer my question.

Most people were fairly indifferent to Floyd back then, so don't play the hate card.

Back then we didn't have any polls for the fight, so all the 60-40 polls you see for Castillo is new.

[Cletus Funk]

Answer the question.

Back then we didn't have any polls for the fight, so all the 60-40 polls you see for Castillo is new.