Tszyu Was Rated #3 p4p When Hatton Defeated Him

[bsrizpac]

Mosely wants to fight him now - why won't PBF do it? Did he retire to keep his "0"? People on this board say welterweight has the best boxers - is this the right time for PBF to retire? Maybe when Mosely is 40, PBF might come out of retirement and fight him but right now Mosely is TOO young for his age...

Again you're making stuff up. Proove that Mosely wanted the fight. he SPECIFICALLY ducked Floyd when offered the fight before the Oscar fight.

But it seems like people are just going to ignore that.

[Hydro]

Tszyu was rated # 3 p4p by Ring Magazine when Hatton won his 11th round TKO.

Has Floyd Mayweather ever defeated anyone rated at the time in the top 5 p4p?

Chico was ranked #5 on the p4p list in The Ring when Floyd beat him.

Check the issue for the awards for 2000, with Felix Trinidad winning "Fighter of the Year", and on the cover.

[Guest]

Chico was ranked #5 on the p4p list in The Ring when Floyd beat him.

Check the issue for the awards for 2000, with Felix Trinidad winning "Fighter of the Year", and on the cover.

Was Chico that high? I thought he was like 9th or 10th. Still a P4P fighter, though...

[kayjay]

I can't believe Chico was ever that high. With all due respect, it's clear that ranking was a mistake.

[PunchyMcGee]

Rankings can be suspect. How can you not give PBF credit for his wins over Chico Corales, Jose Luis Castillo, Chicanito Hernandez, Angel Manfredy, Jesus Chavez, Famoso Hernandez and DLH.

[realheavyhands]

you have to ask yourself first, who, in mayweathers divisions has even been rated that high other than himself?

DONT PROTECT THE GUILTYMAYWEAHER NEVER FOUGHT A TOP 15-20 GUY

[realheavyhands]

Rankings can be suspect. How can you not give PBF credit for his wins over Chico Corales, Jose Luis Castillo, Chicanito Hernandez, Angel Manfredy, Jesus Chavez, Famoso Hernandez and DLH.

FIGHTING GOOD FIGHTERS IS GREAT BUT BEATING ELITE FIGHTERS MAKE U A GREAT

[ThaHorseman]

FIGHTING GOOD FIGHTERS IS GREAT BUT BEATING ELITE FIGHTERS MAKE U A GREAT

Name any fighter better than Hernandez and Chico at 130 that Floyd didn't fight. Name any fighter better than Castillo at 135. He fought the "elite" in those divisions and he fought the best at 147 (the undisputed champ and the previous undisputed champ). You can't blame him for there not being any "elite" fighters in his era. Let me guess James Kirkland should be considered elite? Maybe Andre Berto? Since according to you they both would beat PBF right now.

[realheavyhands]

Name any fighter better than Hernandez and Chico at 130 that Floyd didn't fight. Name any fighter better than Castillo at 135. He fought the "elite" in those divisions and he fought the best at 147 (the undisputed champ and the previous undisputed champ). You can't blame him for there not being any "elite" fighters in his era. Let me guess James Kirkland should be considered elite? Maybe Andre Berto? Since according to you they both would beat PBF right now.

NEITHER OF THEM WERE EVEN CLOSE TO P4P FIGHTERS.. AND THAT WAS A JOKE.. LOOK WHAT WINKY HAS DONE BEAT SHANE MOVED UP TO FIGHT TRINIDAD AND TAYLOR.. MOVED AGAIN TO FIGHT HOPKINS.. THATS ****IN A P4P FIGHTER.. HOPKINS AND TAYLOR BOTH ARE IN THE TOP 10 P4P AND WINKY MOVED UP TWICE TO FIGHT THEM .. FLOYD DUCKS THE BEST AND ****S THE REST

[Cletus Funk]

Name any fighter better than Hernandez and Chico at 130 that Floyd didn't fight. Name any fighter better than Castillo at 135. He fought the "elite" in those divisions and he fought the best at 147 (the undisputed champ and the previous undisputed champ). You can't blame him for there not being any "elite" fighters in his era. Let me guess James Kirkland should be considered elite? Maybe Andre Berto? Since according to you they both would beat PBF right now.

Casamayor.