Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[TRUE WARRIOR]

Castillo didn't win a round until the 6th. PLEASE.

no way man. have you watch the fight lately? castillo was robbed worse than margarito against williams.

[deliveryman]

no way man. have you watch the fight lately? castillo was robbed worse than margarito against williams.

And all credibility just went down the drain.

Next.

[robjr]

no way man. have you watch the fight lately? castillo was robbed worse than margarito against williams.

its fair to say yer a biased fan of mexican fighters.. I also agree that castillo beat mayweather... but...

Margarito did not beat paul williams.

[TRUE WARRIOR]

And all credibility just went down the drain.

Next.

man you dont even watch fights. when you see a black fighter you automatically think they won.

[aljon]

Castillo didn't win a round until the 6th. PLEASE. Or at the very least could very well argue so.

Minus the point deductions to both fighters, made this essentially an 11 round fight.

Do the math.

Close fight. No one was "robbed".

It wasn't a close enough to say "no one was robbed", he was robbed, watch the fight again, the very least you can do is score it a draw but there is no way in hell Mayweather won that fight, Castillo wasn't even hurt and he gave plenty of punishment to Mayweather.. Last time I watched the fight I was very frustrated by the judges score cards..

[deliveryman]

It wasn't a close enough to say "no one was robbed", he was robbed, watch the fight again, the very least you can do is score it a draw but there is no way in hell Mayweather won that fight, Castillo wasn't even hurt and he gave plenty of punishment to Mayweather.. Last time I watched the fight I was very frustrated by the judges score cards..

I agree, but fights are scored by rounds. It's a damn shame Castillo didn't spread that punishment out over the course of 12 rounds, because he was sleeping the first 5 rounds.

[robjr]

man you dont even watch fights. when you see a black fighter you automatically think they won.

Let me guess, you probably think oscar deserved the decision against sturm?

[crold1]

I had the first fight 6-5-1 for Castillo and the second for Floyd 7-5. It's a shame the first didn't go to JLC; would have loved to see a third.

[wmute]

i wasnt talk about the rematch. i just said mayweather became a coward after castillo gave him the worst beating of his life. this is the truth!!!!!!!!

you said:

"he made mayweather into a coward who has been afraid to fight a real challenge since casitllo."

I think it is bull****, but not only I think it is bull****:

it is logically inconsistent considering there was a rematch 6 months later

[IchiBonDj]

I thought they settled it themselves in the rematch.