Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[Run]

the judges messed up big time.

They started scoring rounds for the up and coming athletic fighter......while assuming the Mexican was just cannon fodder. It wasn't until the late rounds they realized they ****ed up bad, but were too lazy to re do the math.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[squealpiggy]

So is the debate settled now?

[wmute]

its good to see the people on boxing scene recognize that castillo was robbed blind in this fight. castillo dominated this fight and he made mayweather into a coward who has been afraid to fight a real challenge since casitllo.

do you realize how ridiculous is your post in view of the rematch which took place 6 months later?

[TRUE WARRIOR]

No, No it wasn't close.

Floyd lost on the cards 116-112. I've watched that fight like seven times and some times I scored it even wider for JLC.

i think i scored 115-111 for castillo. i havent watch in a long time. but still i remember this as the biggest robbery in the history of boxing. the judges should be ashamed of themselves because they are blind or were paid off by mayweather. even the fans know after the fight who really won since they boo mayweather.

[TRUE WARRIOR]

do you realize how ridiculous is your post in view of the rematch which took place 6 months later?

i wasnt talk about the rematch. i just said mayweather became a coward after castillo gave him the worst beating of his life. this is the truth!!!!!!!!

[aljon]

I had it a draw the first time I watched it, but it was doubtful, I always kept leaning on Castillo, I'm talking about the first time I watched it, but then after I watched it again I'm like "wtf was I thinking".. Castillo won this fight, Mayweather didn't do enough to win, he didn't deserve to win, he didn't even show any expression in his face when they were announcing the score cards because he probably knew he didn't deserve it..
Castillo gave more punishment, was busier and should've gotten the UD..

[TRUE WARRIOR]

I had it a draw the first time I watched it, but it was doubtful, I always kept leaning on Castillo, I'm talking about the first time I watched it, but then after I watched it again I'm like "wtf was I thinking".. Castillo won this fight, Mayweather didn't do enough to win, he didn't deserve to win, he didn't even show any expression in his face when they were announcing the score cards because he probably knew he didn't deserve it..
Castillo gave more punishment, was busier and should've gotten the UD..

do you agree this is the biggest robbery in the history of boxing??

[aljon]

do you agree this is the biggest robbery in the history of boxing??

Noway, I mean it could be considered a robbery by many people, including me, but there has been worse like Lewis-Holyfield I, that was much worse..

[deliveryman]

Castillo didn't win a round until the 6th. PLEASE. Or at the very least could strongly argue so.

Minus the point deductions to both fighters, made this essentially an 11 round fight.

Do the math.

Close fight. No one was "robbed".

[robjr]

I truly believe castillo won that fight.