Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[King Tyson]

i truly believed castillo won the first one.

[Guest]

Nobodies opinion has any effect on the outcome of Augustus/Burton either. Doesn't change the fact the wrong guy was awarded the decision.

Mayweather-Castillo and Augustus-Burton are not comparable, so there's no point in bringing that up.

If I had posted a similar thread for Augustus-Burton, Burton would have but one vote from Steelhammer86 and that's about it...

[sonofisis]

Mayweather won that fight, people need to let it go..

[-Hyperion-]

i truly believed castillo won the first one.

everyone who isnt a floyd fanboy does......

[Winkyftw!]

The first time i saw the bout i thought the castillo won the fight...

But then, listening to the advice given to me by some people on this site, i turned the volume off and watched the fight again. When i did this, i scored the bout 115-113 for Mayweather. I still remember pumping my fist when PBF went toe to toe against castillo in of the later rounds, and beat him at his own game. It was a close fight, but Mayweathers clean punching won the fight for him imo.

[C.Y.]

floyd won that fight
and it was close

[TRUE WARRIOR]

floyd won that fight
and it was close

it was not that close. i dont see anyway to score it but for castillo. and you need to take down that avatar with that mallate disrespecting the mexican colors.

[jujuman]

the best way to settle this will be to post the fight round by round and we all make comments as to why we give either of them a particular round that way we get to see what exactly we are voting on. yes we have seen the fight but ill like to see why a round ill give to castillo should go to flyod, i want to see the comments for each round so i understand who exactly im arguing with.

[Spontaneous]

A lot of immature posts in this thread, but I had Castillo 115-113. I saw the fight only watch and that was when it happened. If I saw it again it'd probably change or stay the same.

[robjr]

Mayweather won that fight, people need to let it go..

wtf r u smokin ? either than floyds pole..