Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[{BrownBomber}]

I made it public just to see which votes could be taken seriously. Take out the alts and irrational haters and it's probably 50/50...

BULL****.......... I only see about 3 respectable votes for Floyd to about 10 for Castillo. Ive been here a long time and I know most of the users here.

Fact is kid, most people think Castillo won the fight. Get over it, you're in the minority.Your opinion differs from other people, big ****ing deal. There is no way around it, I made this same poll like 2 years ago and it was the same result.

[Knicksman20]

Mayweather won the fight. The HBO cheerleaders once again manipulate the publics view by not calling the fight correctly. The crowd was very pro Mexican that night & would react to non punches landing just about every time. Yes JLC made the fight close but it was too little to late. I equate this fight to the Pac JMM fight where alot of people were so caught up by JMM's rally that they think he swept from the 2nd-12th which is far from what happened.

[Joartcc3]

did he or did he not win the 1st five rounds?

Judah easily won 4 rounds and yet still lost by a wide margin. You don't win by just winning for 5 rounds.

Common sense actually.

[Joartcc3]

BULL****.......... I only see about 3 respectable votes for Floyd to about 10 for Castillo. Ive been here a long time and I know most of the users here.

Fact is kid, most people think Castillo won the fight. Get over it, you're in the minority.Your opinion differs from other people, big ****ing deal. There is no way around it, I made this same poll like 2 years ago and it was the same result.

Between your opinion and data from the fight, we both know what stands.

[cortdawg25]

Judah easily won 4 rounds and yet still lost by a wide margin. You don't win by just winning for 5 rounds.

Common sense actually.

so you indirectly saying he did win 5 rds straight, ok we getting somewhere...now my follow up ?? Did Floyd lose 7 straight after that? Better yet did Floyd not win 2 more rds after the 1st 5?

[Guest]

BULL****.......... I only see about 3 respectable votes for Floyd to about 10 for Castillo. Ive been here a long time and I know most of the users here.

Fact is kid, most people think Castillo won the fight. Get over it, you're in the minority.Your opinion differs from other people, big ****ing deal. There is no way around it, I made this same poll like 2 years ago and it was the same result.

It's a shame that only those in the minority know anything about judging fights with their brains and not their hearts...

Mayweather clearly won the first 4 rounds. Most would give him the 5th too. After that, Castillo came on but he did not sweep every single round after the 5th...

[machotime]

I gave Mayweather 5 rounds and 5 rounds only... I have watched the fight at least 6 times and have always scored it 5 rounds for Mayweather..

Problem is that Mayweather was supposed to win... he was the up and coming fighter and politics definately played a significant role.

[cortdawg25]

I gave Mayweather 5 rounds and 5 rounds only... I have watched the fight at least 6 times and have always scored it 5 rounds for Mayweather..

Problem is that Mayweather was supposed to win... he was the up and coming fighter and politics definately played a significant role.

WOW!! what 5 rds you give him?

[{BrownBomber}]

I gave Mayweather 5 rounds and 5 rounds only... I have watched the fight at least 6 times and have always scored it 5 rounds for Mayweather..

Problem is that Mayweather was supposed to win... he was the up and coming fighter and politics definately played a significant role.

This is about right.

[-EX-]

I gave Floyd the fight 7 to 5 one round being close so maybe a draw. I haven't watched it in a while.