Is De La Hoya top 10 all time at welterweight?

[ShoulderRoll]

Or for that matter do you consider him top 10 all time in any of the other weight classes he competed in?

[Bolo Punch]

No........

[IronDanHamza]

Absolutely not. Not even close either.

He's just about Top 20-25.

[Marcov]

No!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[joseph5620]

Or for that matter do you consider him top 10 all time in any of the other weight classes he competed in?

No, and not even close.

[Cardinal Buck]

Head to head I'm sure he's top 10 at 140 or 130. Possibly 135, but it's obviously a lot deeper there.

[ShoulderRoll]

Yeah, head to head his rating would be different than if you compare resumes.

For example Basilio spent a lot more years at welter than De La Hoya did but I don't think I would favor him to beat Oscar in a head to head matchup.

[JAB5239]

No, to deep a division.

[MRBOOMER]

No. From 11-20 tho somewhere in their maybe I can't think of twenty guys right now that would be ahead but I thought of a few and once I started to think of them the possibility of him being in the top ten just didn't add up.

[rightsideup]

Yeah, head to head his rating would be different than if you compare resumes.

For example Basilio spent a lot more years at welter than De La Hoya did but I don't think I would favor him to beat Oscar in a head to head matchup.

I favor basilio