Does anyone on either Klits resume beat Ali?

[The_Demon]

If you're going to insist on the 37 year old Lewis as an opponent then I'll insist on a 37 year old Ali as his opponent. Who wins that?

Im pretty sure TS meant 'does anyone on the Klits resume beat a prime Ali',i assume so anyway,and the answer is no,that is all

[IronDanHamza]

If you're going to insist on the 37 year old Lewis as an opponent then I'll insist on a 37 year old Ali as his opponent. Who wins that?

I'm not insisting on a 37 year old Lennox Lewis I'm saying you have to compare it was a 37 year old Lewis because the question is; "Does anyone on either of Klitschko's resume beat Ali?" and as far as I'm aware the Lewis that Klitschko fought was 37 years old.

And I'm pretty sure that the TS is asking who on either Klitschko's resume would beat a prime Ali.

Which the answer is; No.

[nomadman]

Im pretty sure TS meant 'does anyone on the Klits resume beat a prime Ali',i assume so anyway,and the answer is no,that is all

He should have said that then. He didn't, so anyone can assume anything they like.

[The_Demon]

He should have said that then. He didn't, so anyone can assume anything they like.

Well you assume he means the versions of opponents that the Klits actually fought,thats why he said 'the klits resume',and why wouldnt it be prime Ali? isnt it always a prime version of a fighter when talking about fantasy match-ups,unless stated otherwise

[IronDanHamza]

He should have said that then. He didn't, so anyone can assume anything they like.

It's common sense.

He's obviously asking whether anyone Klitschko(s) beat - meaning obviously the versions of the fighters they beat, could beat a prime Muhammad Ali.

Which again, the answer is obviously no.

[nomadman]

Well you assume he means the versions of opponents that the Klits actually fought,thats why he said 'the klits resume',and why wouldnt it be prime Ali? isnt it always a prime version of a fighter when talking about fantasy match-ups,unless stated otherwise

Not in this scenario, clearly.

[nomadman]

It's common sense.

He's obviously asking whether anyone Klitschko(s) beat - meaning obviously the versions of the fighters they beat, could beat a prime Muhammad Ali.

Which again, the answer is obviously no.

He never said anything about fighters they beat, only faced.

[The_Demon]

It's common sense.

He's obviously asking whether anyone Klitschko(s) beat - meaning obviously the versions of the fighters they beat, could beat a prime Muhammad Ali.

Which again, the answer is obviously no.

Case closed

[The_Demon]

He never said anything about fighters they beat, only faced.

So its obviously an old Lewis then isnt it,thats the version Vitali actually faced

[IronDanHamza]

He never said anything about fighters they beat, only faced.

Faced, beat, same difference.

Vitali fought a 37 year old version of Lennox Lewis so that's the version that is to be compared to Muhammad Ali in this situation.