Vitali Klitschko vs. Rocky Marciano

[The Old LefHook]

No one would even answer my question. They are afraid to. Makes them look ******. Who did this Vitaly beat? He beat no one and was beat up by a long in tooth Lewis. Hilarious.

Well, of course Obed Sullivan was an ATG. Herbie Hyde as well. Ed Mahone, what a fighter. Don't forget the great Danny Williams. Then there was Sam Peter who could barely beat Toney. Of course Gomez, Arreola and Johnson were stellar ATGs. Don't forget the loss to Byrd because his shoulder was sore.

He did not fight anybody. If he did a few times, he lost. He was not a great champion and not a great fighter.

[Ivich]

No one would even answer my question. They are afraid to. Makes them look ******. Who did this Vitaly beat? He beat no one and was beat up by a long in tooth Lewis. Hilarious.

Well, of course Obed Sullivan was an ATG. Herbie Hyde as well. Ed Mahone, what a fighter. Don't forget the great Danny Williams. Then there was Sam Peter who could barely beat Toney. Of course Gomez, Arreola and Johnson were stellar ATGs. Don't forget the loss to Byrd because his shoulder was sore.

He did not fight anybody. If he did a few times, he lost. He was not a great champion and not a great fighter.

Harry Mathews 179lbs
Roland Lastarza183lbs
Don ****ell fat at 205lbs
37 yr old Louis a career high 213lbs
38 yrs old Walcott196lbs
39/41 yrs old Moore188lbs
Pudgy Rex Layne193lbs
High mileage Ezzard Charles185lbs
Not exactly a stellar resume either.
Vitali was not a great fighter.but he was a very good one,who knew how to use his physical attributes and with his size advantage 60lbs ,nearly 9 inches of height ,good power ,80 inch reach and top chin,he would be too much for Rocky.

ps I''d pick Herbie Hide to beat;
****ell
Mathews
Lastarza
Layne
And he would give those versions of the old champs a tough nights work.

[eyebgooglingmyself]

Why do so many boxing forums have silly threads like this? Vitali K was 6'7 and 240/250. Marciano was a 5'10 180 pound guy. Why do some people act like they can't grasp there are weight classes for a reason. Marciano could be a small cruiser weight today. Marciano would never make it out of the first round against Wlad, Vitali, George Foreman, Mike Tyson, ect.

[Willie Pep 229]

Why do so many boxing forums have silly threads like this? Vitali K was 6'7 and 240/250. Marciano was a 5'10 180 pound guy. Why do some people act like they can't grasp there are weight classes for a reason. Marciano could be a small cruiser weight today. Marciano would never make it out of the first round against Wlad, Vitali, George Foreman, Mike Tyson, ect.

Ah! So you are here now with the absolute answer, no longer do we need to bother with debate, discussion, and argument. We need only to ask you. Were have you been all this time?

[The Old LefHook]

Harry Mathews 179lbs
Roland Lastarza183lbs
Don ****ell fat at 205lbs
37 yr old Louis a career high 213lbs
38 yrs old Walcott196lbs
39/41 yrs old Moore188lbs
Pudgy Rex Layne193lbs
High mileage Ezzard Charles185lbs
Not exactly a stellar resume either.
Vitali was not a great fighter.but he was a very good one,who knew how to use his physical attributes and with his size advantage 60lbs ,nearly 9 inches of height ,good power ,80 inch reach and top chin,he would be too much for Rocky.

ps I''d pick Herbie Hide to beat;
****ell
Mathews
Lastarza
Layne
And he would give those versions of the old champs a tough nights work.

Yeah, change the subject to Marciano.

[Ivich]

Yeah, change the subject to Marciano.

The subject IS Marciano and how he would fare against Vitali and one way to measure that is to compare their opposition and replaceVitali with Rocky and vice versa.
Another is to pit each man's opposition against each other,and I made an observation that Herbie Hide, whom Vitali relieved of his alphabet belt in emphatic style ,would do very well against the majority of Rocky's opponents.
YOU brought up Vitali's opposition and the quality of it!
Does that only apply ONE WAY?
Are we not permitted to examine Rocky's opposition?

Marciano was the greater fighter,the only name of consequence missing from his resume is Valdes.
There are quite a few missing from Vitali's
Tyson
Holyfield
Tua
Barrett
Ruiz
Oquendo
Golota
Brewster
Valuev
Povetkin
Chagaev
For example.
Now relax chill out, it's okay there are no booby traps for you here.
No boxers who changed their names to Islamic ones.
Rahman Mustaphiano?
Oh Boy! You wouldn't be so keen on him then would you! LOL

[Anthony342]

The subject IS Marciano and how he would fare against Vitali and one way to measure that is to compare their opposition and replaceVitali with Rocky and vice versa.
Another is to pit each man's opposition against each other,and I made an observation that Herbie Hide, whom Vitali relieved of his alphabet belt in emphatic style ,would do very well against the majority of Rocky's opponents.
YOU brought up Vitali's opposition and the quality of it!
Does that only apply ONE WAY?
Are we not permitted to examine Rocky's opposition?

Marciano was the greater fighter,the only name of consequence missing from his resume is Valdes.
There are quite a few missing from Vitali's
Tyson
Holyfield
Tua
Barrett
Ruiz
Oquendo
Golota
Brewster
Valuev
Povetkin
Chagaev
For example.
Now relax chill out, it's okay there are no booby traps for you here.
No boxers who changed their names to Islamic ones.
Rahman Mustaphiano?
Oh Boy! You wouldn't be so keen on him then would you! LOL

I thought this was settled already. Vitali in 8-9 rounds.

[Ascended]

This is a mismatch its obvious rock would lose only crazy idiots say rock would win to outdated

[shawnkemp804]

Vitali by knockout with the first legit punch he lands.

[Willie Pep 229]

Vitali by knockout with the first legit punch he lands.

Is there someone else there we can talk to?