Who Would You Take Out The IBHOF?

[JAB5239]

SO,............. that's why you're banned,,,,,,,,, you surely were thinking about some other Bob Foster after all it's a common name,......... what were you thinking ?????????????????????????????????????????????????? ?????????????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????????????????????????

McGoorty, you've never posted here before? Never seen frankenfranks all time top 10 heavyweight? Have a gander at one of his great heavyweight lists.


1. Vitali Klitschko
2. George Foreman
3. Mike Tyson
4. Muhammad Ali
5. Lennox Lewis
6. Larry Holmes
7. Wladimir Klitschko
8. Oliver McCall
9. David Tua
10. Evander Holyfield

11. Ikemefula Ibeabuchi
12. Rid**** Bowe
13. Tony Tucker
14. James Douglas
15. Joe Louis
16. Joe Frazier
17. Chris Byrd
18. Sultanakhmed Ibragimov
19. Nikolay Valuev
20. Sam Peter

21. Ross Puritty
22. Jameel McCline
23. Lamon Brewster
24. Dominick Guinn
25. James Smith
26. Ray Austin
27. Lance Whitaker
28. Joe Mesi
29. Michael Grant
30. James Toney

31. Donovan Ruddock
32. Frank Bruno
33. Tim Witherspoon
34. Gerrie Cooney
35. Orlin Norris
36. Greg Page
37. George Chuvalo
38. Oscar Bonavena
39. Ron Lyle
40. Jimmy Young


41. Jerry Quarry
42. Earnie Shavers
43. Ken Norton
44. Charles Liston
45. Sam Langford
46. Joe Jeannette
47. Harry Wills
48. Rocky Marciano
49. Jack Johnson
50. Jack Dempsey

51. Max Baer
52. Max Schmelling
53. Chris Arreola
54. Michael Spinks
55. Michael Moorer
56. Oleg Maskaev
57. Hassim Rahman
58. Corrie Sanders
59. John Ruiz
60. Kirk Johnson

61. Corey Sanders
62. Martin Rogan
63. Matt Skelton
64. Danny Williams
65. Jesse Fergusson
66. Ray Mercer
67. Alexander Povetkin
68. Eric Esch
69. Brian Nielsen
70. Audley Harisson


71. Mike Hunter
72. ****y Ryann
73. Michael Sprott
74. Jimmy Ellis
75. Floyd Patterson
76. Bert Cooper
77. Buster Mathis Jr.
78. Marvis Frazier

[kendom]

McGoorty, you've never posted here before? Never seen frankenfranks all time top 10 heavyweight? Have a gander at one of his great heavyweight lists.


1. Vitali Klitschko
2. George Foreman
3. Mike Tyson
4. Muhammad Ali
5. Lennox Lewis
6. Larry Holmes
7. Wladimir Klitschko
8. Oliver McCall
9. David Tua
10. Evander Holyfield

11. Ikemefula Ibeabuchi
12. Rid**** Bowe
13. Tony Tucker
14. James Douglas
15. Joe Louis
16. Joe Frazier
17. Chris Byrd
18. Sultanakhmed Ibragimov
19. Nikolay Valuev
20. Sam Peter

21. Ross Puritty
22. Jameel McCline
23. Lamon Brewster
24. Dominick Guinn
25. James Smith
26. Ray Austin
27. Lance Whitaker
28. Joe Mesi
29. Michael Grant
30. James Toney

31. Donovan Ruddock
32. Frank Bruno
33. Tim Witherspoon
34. Gerrie Cooney
35. Orlin Norris
36. Greg Page
37. George Chuvalo
38. Oscar Bonavena
39. Ron Lyle
40. Jimmy Young


41. Jerry Quarry
42. Earnie Shavers
43. Ken Norton
44. Charles Liston
45. Sam Langford
46. Joe Jeannette
47. Harry Wills
48. Rocky Marciano
49. Jack Johnson
50. Jack Dempsey

51. Max Baer
52. Max Schmelling
53. Chris Arreola
54. Michael Spinks
55. Michael Moorer
56. Oleg Maskaev
57. Hassim Rahman
58. Corrie Sanders
59. John Ruiz
60. Kirk Johnson

61. Corey Sanders
62. Martin Rogan
63. Matt Skelton
64. Danny Williams
65. Jesse Fergusson
66. Ray Mercer
67. Alexander Povetkin
68. Eric Esch
69. Brian Nielsen
70. Audley Harisson


71. Mike Hunter
72. ****y Ryann
73. Michael Sprott
74. Jimmy Ellis
75. Floyd Patterson
76. Bert Cooper
77. Buster Mathis Jr.
78. Marvis Frazier

This has to be some sort of joke.

[StarshipTrooper]

This has to be some sort of joke.

The dude was dead serious. More recently in NSB, under one of his alts, he was trying to convince people that being fat makes you a better fighter :hahahaha9:

Poet

[JAB5239]

frankenfrank thread from ESB.

If you ever dared to dispute me in one of these often argued subjects of greatness , quality , etc , post your own entire top 30 prior to having any argument against mine.
Remember : if you don't have a better alternative STFU !
Suggestion : for those who do insist on correcting me , you'd better make some minor (up/down 1-2 places) fixes/swaps in my lists , maybe even take some of the lowest 5 in favor of someone whom I forgot or still don't know enough about .

(S)HW :
1.Vitali Klitschko
2. George Foreman
3. Nikolay Valuev
4. Oliver McCall
5. Maufaufau Tavito Sita (David Tua to some)
6. Mike Tyson
7. Rid**** Bowe
8. Muhammad Ali
9. Evander Holyfield
10. Lennox Lewis

11. Ike Ibeabuchi
12. Joe Louis
13. Joe Frazier
14. Wladimir Klitschko
15. Chris Byrd
16. Jameel McCline
17. James Smith
18. Tony Tucker
19. Lamon Brewster
20. Sultanakhmed Ibragimov

21. Ross Puritty
22. James Douglas
23. Larry Holmes
24. Frank Bruno
25. Henry Akiwande
26. Rocco Marchegiano
27. Sam Langford
28. Charles Liston
29. George Chuvalo
30. Bob Cleroux

31. Orlin Norris
32. Jesse Fergusson
33. Bert Cooper

P4P :
1. Sam Langford
2. Henry Armstrong
3. James Toney
4. Roberto Duran
5. Muhammad Qawi
6. Maufaufau Sita ( David Tua )
7. Joe Walcott
8. Walker Smith Jr.
9. Young Peter Jackson
10. Mike Tyson

11. Oliver McCall
12. Chris Byrd
13. Orlin Norris
14. Kid Gavillan
15. Ray Leonard
16. Mike McCallum
17. Salvador Sanchez
18. Julio Cesar Chavez
19. Juan LaPorte
20. Hector Camacho

21. Rocco Marchegiano
22. Charley Burley
23. Barney Ross
24. Carmen Basilio
25. Khaosai Galaxy
26. Roy Jones Jr.
27. Manny Pacquiao
28. Orlando Canizales
29. Ricardo Lopez
30. Eder Jofre

31. Jorge Fernando Castro
32. Juan Manuel Marquez
33. Lamon Brewster
34. Marlon Starling
35. Joe Frazier
36. Ezzard Charles
37. Arnold Cream
38. Simon Brown
39. Aaron Davis
40. Dingaan Thobela


41. Sultanakhmed Ibragimov
42. Marvin Hagler
43. Carlos Monzon
44. Rubin Carter
45. Rodrigo Valdez
46. Harry Greb
47. Jose Luis Lopez
48. **** Tiger
49. Emile Griffith
50. Archie Wright

51. Reggie Johnson
52. Chris Eubanks
53. Steve Collins
54. Sanderline Williams
55. Isufu Quartey
56. Frankie Randall
57. Laurent Boudouani
58. Ronald Wright
59. Orzubek Nazarov
60. Carlos Palomino

61. Carlos Ortiz
62. Jose Napoles
63. Duilio Loi
64. Pete Santol
65. Doug Jones
66. Oscar Delahoya
67. Alexis Arguello
68. Ken Buchanan
69. Esteban DeJesus
70. Baltasar Sangchili


71. Tony Canzoneri
72. Lou Ambers
73. Sixto Escobar
74. Ike Williams
75. Beau Jack
76. Vinny Pazienza
77. Jeff Chandler
78. Harry Jeffra
79. Willie Pep
80. Keith Holmes

81. Lew Jenkins
82. Sammy Angott
83. Yuri Arbachakov
84. Mark Johnson


Hall Of Shame :
1. Bernard Hopkins
2. Fritzie Zivic
3. Muhammad Ali
4. Mysterious Billy Smith
5. Gene Fullmer (although I didn't notice anything in one of his bouts with Basilio)
6. Panama Al Brown
7. Mike Tyson
8. Rocco Marchegiano (I didn't note his elbows)
9. Evander "Head/Evan Fields" Holyfield
10. Felix Trinidad
11. Antonio Margarito
12. Luis Resto

LHW (175lbs) :
1. Rocco Marchegiano
2. Sam Langford
3. Ezzard Charles
4. Muhammad Qawi
5. Michael Spinks
6. Floyd Patterson
7. Archie Wright
8. Gene Tunney
9. Harry Greb
10. Billy Conn

11. Tommy Gibbons
12. Tiger Jack Fox
13. John Henry Lewis
14. Al Gainer
15. Harold Johnson
16. Doug Jones
17. Roy Jones Jr.
18. Lloyd Marshall
19. Joey Maxim
20. Antonio Tarver

21. Glen Johnson
22. Michael Moorer
23. Virgil Hill
24. Muhammad Saad
25. Dariusz Michalczewski
26. Charles Williams
27. Henry Maske
28. Leonard Morrow
29. Oakland Billy Smith
30. Eddie Mustaffa Muhammad

welterweight :
1. Walker Smith Jr.
2. Kid Gavillan
3. Sam Langford
4. Young Peter Jackson
5. Ray Leonard
6. Carmen Basilio
7. Henry Armstrong
8. Marlon Starling
9. Emile Griffith
10. Joe Walcott


11. Jose Napoles
12. Simon Brown
13. Donald Sample (Curry)
14. Paul Williams
15. Miguel Cotto
16. Shane Mosley
17. Manny Pacquiao
18. Oscar Delahoya
19. Jose Luis Lopez
20. Thomas Hearns

21. Isufu Quartery
22. Barney Ross
23. Aaron Davis
24. Roberto Duran
25. Young Corbett 3
26. Ricardo Mayorga
27. Carlos Palomino
28. Vernon Forrest
29. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
30. Danny Perez

31. Joshua Clottey
32. Lovermore N'dou
33. Kermit Cintron

[GJC]

Love the way he uses the fighters real name as of to impart some deep knowledge. And then he starts to type and the illusion ends.....

[NChristo]

Love the way he uses the fighters real name as of to impart some deep knowledge. And then he starts to type and the illusion ends.....

Was just about to say this, he ALWAYS did it and it's what most got on my nerves, more so then most of the rubbish he would spout.

Credit to him though, he was persistant and would not give up, he gave some good debates at times even if most of them were ludicrous

[GJC]

He posted these lists on here? Can't believe I missed them. I'm looking at the p4p list and I'm actually trying to see if there's a hidden code or something like if you were looking at a jumble of letters and numbers!

[GJC]

Was just about to say this, he ALWAYS did it and it's what most got on my nerves, more so then most of the rubbish he would spout.

Credit to him though, he was persistant and would not give up, he gave some good debates at times even if most of them were ludicrous

Thing is he used to put in such random fighters you doubted yourself! "That is Walcott's real name isn't it, or is there another Arnold Cream he means?"

[Boxing Bob]

I can only judge fighters from 1970 on.
Undeserving-Carbajal, Cuevas, McGuigan, Palomino, Tsyu, and Qawi
Borderline undeserving- Chacon, Cokes, Fenech, Galindez, Mitchell, and Rosario

[JAB5239]

[B]1. Vitali Klitschko
2. George Foreman
3. Mike Tyson
4. Muhammad Ali
5. Lennox Lewis
6. Larry Holmes
7. Wladimir Klitschko
8. Oliver McCall
9. David Tua
10. Evander Holyfield



(S)HW :
1.Vitali Klitschko
2. George Foreman
3. Nikolay Valuev
4. Oliver McCall
5. Maufaufau Tavito Sita (David Tua to some)
6. Mike Tyson
7. Rid**** Bowe
8. Muhammad Ali
9. Evander Holyfield
10. Lennox Lewis

He posted these lists on here? Can't believe I missed them. I'm looking at the p4p list and I'm actually trying to see if there's a hidden code or something like if you were looking at a jumble of letters and numbers!

One list was here, the other from ESB. Anyone else notice the inconsistency in the 2 different Heavyweight top 10's lists?