Poll: Is Duran a top 5 AT fighter?

[MalevolentBite]

Welp, just a matter of semantics then, figured as much. And though you don't rate heavyweights P4P, sticking with the definition that came up for SRR to get his respect, there are many of us here who do (me included). For me, I rate P4P relative to your weight class, so heavyweights can be included too.

Yup. I am old school and thats fine. I will just sit here and enjoy everyone's list form their opinion. If its relative to people's weight class. There's alot of people who dominated their weight class alot of people didn't mention which is fine.

You can make an argument that Julio Cesar Chavez ar his weight was dominant. Also Carlos Monzón and Hagler but they weren't mentioned here at all.

If we go way back Tony Canzoneri

[DeeMoney]

Yup. I am old school and thats fine. I will just sit here and enjoy everyone's list form their opinion. If its relative to people's weight class. There's alot of people who dominated their weight class alot of people didn't mention which is fine.

You can make an argument that Julio Cesar Chavez ar his weight was dominant. Also Carlos Monzón and Hagler but they weren't mentioned here at all.

If we go way back Tony Canzoneri

Its funny, I do rank JCC, Hagler, and Monzon fairly high too. Not top 5 high, but probably higher than most