Poll: Is Duran a top 5 AT fighter?

[Mr Mitts]

Who do you put above Duran, if anyone?

[Mr Mitts]

Who do have ahead of him. Armstrong?

[IronDanHamza]

Not for me.

Top 15

[Bronson66]

who do you put above duran, if anyone?

A case could be made ,but I think he is just outside it.

[DeeMoney]

I have him top 5, but I do my rankings different than most everyone else, so it would be an apples to oranges type thing

[Mr Mitts]

I am surprised, but only mildly; it am a razor thin decision, at least for me. But it begs the question who then is above him. That requires an individual answer in each case. Since I am asking you who is ahead of him, it is only right I try to name/guess people I think might reasonably be placed above him by some of the folk here.

Robinson
Greb
Langford
Mayweather
Pacquiao
Leonard
Pep
Gans
Ali
??????????????????????

In short, I would like to see your lists up until Duran, if you will. I think I left out one name I had thought of yesterday. Anyway, if you will, please.

[Mr Mitts]

I have him top 5, but I do my rankings different than most everyone else, so it would be an apples to oranges type thing

That's interesting. How do you do your rankings?

[IronDanHamza]

I am surprised, but only mildly; it am a razor thin decision, at least for me. But it begs the question who then is above him. That requires an individual answer in each case. Since I am asking you who is ahead of him, it is only right I try to name/guess people I think might reasonably be placed above him by some of the folk here.

Robinson
Greb
Langford
Mayweather
Pacquiao
Leonard
Pep
Gans
Ali
??????????????????????

In short, I would like to see your lists up until Duran, if you will. I think I left out one name I had thought of yesterday. Anyway, if you will, please.

Above him I would personally rank off the top of my head;

Ezzard Charles
Ray Robinson
Harry Greb
Sam Langford
Muhammad Ali
Benny Leonard
Jimmy McLarnin
Ray Leonard
Floyd Mayweather
Manny Pacquaio
Archie Moore

Can only name 11 off the top of my head, probably missing some people.