Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Greb draws the colorline

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #21
    Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post
    From the book "The sundowners"

    Leo Flynn had signed Panama Joe for a ten round preliminary bout against Al Rogers, an upstate, white middleweight at Syracuse, New York in early December 1919. The main event that night was supposed to have been Harry Greb and Clay Turner. When Flynn and Gans reached Syracuse they learned that Al Rogers had ducked out of his bout with Joe. Citing that he did not wish to fight a black man in front of his home crowd, Rogers, simply begged out. Promoter Joe Dunfee attempted to bring in a late substitute but could find no takers. To add to his problems, the day before the event, Clay Tumer wired from New York City that he had injured his leg and could not meet Greb. The wily Dunfee approached Flynn with the idea that Gans and Greb could draw a similar, if not larger crowd than Greb-Turner. Leo, after asking for more money, agreed. It is unclear as to whether or not Greb knew of the substitution, but when he entered the Arena Athletic Club ring and saw, the long, dark Panama Joe Gans standing across from him, he was not pleased. Harry refused to fight and drew the ire of the crowd when he waved them off as they razzed him. Reddy Mason, Greb's manager, addressed the crowd and attempted to explain the particulars of the situation, but was shouted down quickly. The Synacnur Herald reported that Reddy's speech basically boiled down to the fact that "He and Greb drew the color line". The crowd settled down when Greb took over, pleading his case to the crowd. However, when he used the word "******" in reference to Gans, the crowd roared its disapproval. Panama Joe himself took exception to Harry's slur and began to cross the ring towards his adversary. Greb held up his open hands and immediately apologized to Gans for the wrong doing. Harry then offered to box Young Fischer, who was in the crowd, but the latter was not interested. Harry and Mason then made a quick exit from the ring amid a showering of catcalls and debris. The Herald reported the next day, "Panama Joe Gans is not a champion, but champions and other near champions, such as Greb, would rather avoid such a "tough bird", and Gans scales lighter than Greb While Greb now draws the color line it was just a few years ago that he fought Willie Langford, the colored middleweight at Buffalo. But Greb has since got himself a reputation and can now "pick" his opponents."
    The summer of 1919 was a long and scary one. The "Red Summer" saw the ugly face of racism in America boil over. It began in Chicago in July, when a young black boy went swimming at a Lake Michigan beach. Not a very good swimmer the boy found himself a size-able log to cling onto so that he could join his friends in deeper waters. Unable to control himself or the log the boy slowly drifted over towards a roped off section of the beach with a sign that read, "for Whites only". Panicked by his inability to paddle back towards his friends the boy began to flail wildly. From the beach a group of white men began to taunt the boy and then watched as the boy slipped into the water and drowned. A fight ensued between the white men and a group a black men who had come searching for the boy. When the Chicago police arrived on the scene they refused to arrest any of the white men who had witnessed the drowning but did arrest two of their black attackers. The incident set of rash of riots in Chicago. Whites formed gangs and invaded black neighborhoods, beating their inhabitants, looting stores and burning buildings. Some blacks retaliated by forming their own mobs and committing similar acts in white neighborhoods. By the time the National Guard had restored order, 15 whites had been killed and 153 injured and as many as 23 blacks had been killed and 178 injured. The incidents in Chicago began a chain reaction of similar incidents across the nation, forcing social experts to state that "there might be no solution in sight for America's racial differences". By the time order had been restored, there had been a total of 35 race
    Good Stuff !

    Comment


    • #22
      You got that bit of sundowners from me!


      Because last time I did this Bronson said Sundowners is not a legit source

      I found another one.



      Great find!


      Could not be more obvious youse don't have a clue, are trying to catch up while fighting the narrative I laid out, and are floundering on finding anything that doesn't claim Greb drew the colorline.




      Yup, that page of Sundowners is uploaded. To an account called ManDeLaManche-Marchegiano.


      https://archive.org/details/PanamaGreb



      Pretty ****ing telling isn't it? One man here knows this story. Has known this story. Knows what lead up to it ... I have the pages before and after that page ... and what happened next.




      But since it's a lesson youse don't want to learn do not let that stop you from using the source I gave you LAST time I tried to teach you silly bitches something you don't want to know. Bet your asses remember this time.

      Comment


      • #23
        Originally posted by Marchegiano View Post
        You got that bit of sundowners from me!


        Because last time I did this Bronson said Sundowners is not a legit source

        I found another one.



        Great find!


        Could not be more obvious youse don't have a clue, are trying to catch up while fighting the narrative I laid out, and are floundering on finding anything that doesn't claim Greb drew the colorline.




        Yup, that page of Sundowners is uploaded. To an account called ManDeLaManche-Marchegiano.


        https://archive.org/details/PanamaGreb



        Pretty ****ing telling isn't it? One man here knows this story. Has known this story. Knows what lead up to it ... I have the pages before and after that page ... and what happened next.




        But since it's a lesson youse don't want to learn do not let that stop you from using the source I gave you LAST time I tried to teach you silly bitches something you don't want to know. Bet your asses remember this time.
        You didn't give me that. I emailed the IBRO and got a response back from Bill Paxton with this attached. And the fact is there is still no proof Greb drew a color line when there is substantial proof he fought colored fighters before, during, and after his wife passed away. Just because the Syracuse Herald claimed "Greb and Reddy basically drew the colorline" doesn't it make it true. Just words to sell newspapers with no proof.

        Comment


        • #24
          Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post

          You didn't give me that. I emailed the IBRO and got a response back from Bill Paxton with this attached. And the fact is there is still no proof Greb drew a color line when there is substantial proof he fought colored fighters before, during, and after his wife passed away. Just because the Syracuse Herald claimed "Greb and Reddy basically drew the colorline" doesn't it make it true. Just words to sell newspapers with no proof.
          I would like to see the post in which I said Sundowners was," not a legitimate source",because I have no memory of saying that.

          Comment


          • #25
            Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post

            You didn't give me that. I emailed the IBRO and got a response back from Bill Paxton with this attached. And the fact is there is still no proof Greb drew a color line when there is substantial proof he fought colored fighters before, during, and after his wife passed away. Just because the Syracuse Herald claimed "Greb and Reddy basically drew the colorline" doesn't it make it true. Just words to sell newspapers with no proof.
            Okay buddy, it's been uploaded and ignored for years and you needed Billy to tell you the exact same **** I already did? You'll get no challenge out of me on that front. Super obvious why too.


            No proof he drew the color line except his being quoted drawing the colorline. Amazing.



            Put that ****ing hamster on its wheel and let her run; you're not this dumb. If I thought this page of Sundowners breaks anything I've said here. Why TF did I upload it 5 years ago? I can't even edit Marchegiano posts anymore! I CAN'T post date my usage of this page.



            TF do you think you've proven, found, or done? Even the mild mannered Jab can be made into a silly, small, child, when presented with a lesson he doesn't want to learn?



            Does it say Greb drew the colorline, called Panama a hard R, then ran away and apologized when Panama set toward him? On snap, it does. So, in fact, I could have been even harder on Greb and highlight how he ran from Panama but I didn't because I knew someone here would be a crybaby ***** about it, I just didn't expect that to be you.



            Small, silly, and childish ... gonna cling to half the source while ignoring the other half What the ****. So silly it is YOU who highlights the slur and cowardice like as if YOU have a point there. What the ****?




            I promise you this Jab, Harry Greb's legacy is big enough accepting he once took the easy way out isn't going to hurt it any. Stop being such a ****ing baby or find me a source where Harry Greb does not claim colorline wifey bull**** and excuse Willie.
            Last edited by Marchegiano; 04-23-2025, 08:21 AM.

            Comment


            • #26
              Originally posted by JAB5239 View Post

              You didn't give me that. I emailed the IBRO and got a response back from Bill Paxton with this attached. And the fact is there is still no proof Greb drew a color line when there is substantial proof he fought colored fighters before, during, and after his wife passed away. Just because the Syracuse Herald claimed "Greb and Reddy basically drew the colorline" doesn't it make it true. Just words to sell newspapers with no proof.
              Pretty sure I didn't use the Syracuse Herald for a reason. How many papers you need before something is corroborated?

              Likewise, which of his fights are you suspect of because "just words to sell newspapers with no proof"?

              Comment


              • #27
                Originally posted by Bronson66 View Post

                I would like to see the post in which I said Sundowners was," not a legitimate source",because I have no memory of saying that.
                Then look for it you lazy ****.

                Did Bronson give the criticism Bronson always gives me on every single subject? My sources must be wrong den because I'm not a historian like Pollack and Fleischer?

                Pep didn't like it either. But since Jab went to Billy, who is def above me too, to get the **** I already posted to post back at me, I think it's pretty clear why this memory is so selective.

                Soon enough Bronny here will have a hard time remembering defending Nat






                Let me be super clear because y'all sometimes give me more credit than I deserve. There is nothing humble in this post. Yes, I am telling you, you are beneath me and I am more akin to the men you throw at me than any of you daily posters. You should be ****ing grateful I put up with your bull**** and yes, your bull****, exactly like this, is why the authors who do sign up for forums don't like to post much. Yes I am on that level, that's why youse never cause me any research at all while I just say **** sometimes, off the cuff, and send you ****ers into a spiral of emotions and googling.


                Rock saying know yer role.

                Comment


                • #28
                  Originally posted by Marchegiano View Post

                  Okay buddy, it's been uploaded and ignored for years and you needed Billy to tell you the exact same **** I already did? You'll get no challenge out of me on that front. Super obvious why too.


                  No proof he drew the color line except his being quoted drawing the colorline. Amazing.



                  Put that ****ing hamster on its wheel and let her run; you're not this dumb. If I thought this page of Sundowners breaks anything I've said here. Why TF did I upload it 5 years ago? I can't even edit Marchegiano posts anymore! I CAN'T post date my usage of this page.



                  TF do you think you've proven, found, or done? Even the mild mannered Jab can be made into a silly, small, child, when presented with a lesson he doesn't want to learn?



                  Does it say Greb drew the colorline, called Panama a hard R, then ran away and apologized when Panama set toward him? On snap, it does. So, in fact, I could have been even harder on Greb and highlight how he ran from Panama but I didn't because I knew someone here would be a crybaby ***** about it, I just didn't expect that to be you.



                  Small, silly, and childish ... gonna cling to half the source while ignoring the other half What the ****. So silly it is YOU who highlights the slur and cowardice like as if YOU have a point there. What the ****?




                  I promise you this Jab, Harry Greb's legacy is big enough accepting he once took the easy way out isn't going to hurt it any. Stop being such a ****ing baby or find me a source where Harry Greb does not claim colorline wifey bull**** and excuse Willie.
                  You see it as taking the easy way out. I see it as a fighter frustrated with 2 opponent changes in less than 24 hours. Did Greb use a racist slur? According to the Syracuse Herald. There are no other sources I'm aware of though. Did he really say he "promised his wife". Again, According to the Herald. But that still makes no sense as he fought colored fighters before, during, and after she passed. This says to me that there may be something else at play here. Maybe they were trying to sell papers, I don't know. And the point is neither do you. You're welcome to your opinion, but I'll stand by my own opinion for the reasons I've said.

                  Comment


                  • #29
                    Originally posted by Bronson66 View Post

                    I would like to see the post in which I said Sundowners was," not a legitimate source",because I have no memory of saying that.
                    I am not making the claim here, the poster who is has the onus on him to provide proof of his claim,not me ,and now I politely request that he do so.

                    Since as we now know them, ratings began in1924.Greb fought the following ranked fighters in the years he had left to live .

                    1924
                    Ted Moore no10 at Middle

                    Gene Tunney no 1 at Lhvy

                    Tommy Loughran no9 at Lhvy

                    1925
                    Jimmy Delaney no 10 at Lhvy

                    Maxie Rosenbloom no 3 at Middle

                    Tony Marullo no8 at Lhvy x2

                    Johnny Wilson no5 at Middle

                    Tunney no 1 at Lhvy

                    Allen Town Joe Gans 5 at Middle

                    1926
                    Jimmy Delaney no8 at Lhvy

                    Tiger Flower no1 at Middle
                    Apart from one poster who is busy insulting all and sundry because they do not agree with him.

                    Is there anyone else here who seriously believes Greb bypassed black fighters when he considered them too dangerous?

                    We are being accused of crying,being silly,small ,childish,bitches, being beneath this poster,and in my case, a lazy ****.

                    Has any of us responded in kind to this unwarranted hysteria on the thread?

                    Somebody on this Forum has severe emotional problems and possibly a mental disorder,and it isn't those of us who are in full agreement that Greb did not duck dangerous black fighters.

                    Greb's record emphatically rebuts this ludicrous nonsense better than any posted argument ever could.

                    The absurdity of the original post prompted me to check the date wasn't still April the first!

                    Oh well ,I suppose we should be grateful Klompton is no longer allowed to post here,and give his views on the subject , if he was
                    I suspect the OP might experience a meltdown from which his fragile psyche would never recover.

                    Much Ado About Absolutely Nothing!LOL!
                    Last edited by Bronson66; 04-23-2025, 12:51 PM.
                    Anomalocaris Anomalocaris likes this.

                    Comment


                    • #30
                      - - Seems someone is drawing the colorline with every post, a sorta colorline spam.

                      What about the Rainbow Colorline...yeah!!!

                      Bronson66 Bronson66 likes this.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP