Top 10 Greatest American Fighters?

[Don_Jah]

1 Harry Greb
2 Sugar Ray Robinson
3 Willie Pep
4 Benny Leonard
5 Henry Armstrong
6 Muhammed Ali
7 Tony Canzoneri
8 Jack Dempsey
9 Rocky Marciano
10 Joe Louis

[Slugfester]

In no order:


1 Robinson
2 Ali
3 SR Leonard
4 Benny Leonard
5 Greb
6 Walker
7 Armstrong
8 Pep
9 Hagler
10 Saddler

[QueensburyRules]

1 Harry Greb
2 Sugar Ray Robinson
3 Willie Pep
4 Benny Leonard
5 Henry Armstrong
6 Muhammed Ali
7 Tony Canzoneri
8 Jack Dempsey
9 Rocky Marciano
10 Joe Louis

- - I’d put Joe Louis at the top of that bunch.

Only Dempsey would give him a bother.

[TheOneAboveAll]

Please don't forget the Duke.

[Ivich]

In no order:


1 Robinson
2 Ali
3 SR Leonard
4 Benny Leonard
5 Greb
6 Walker
7 Armstrong
8 Pep
9 Hagler
10 Langford

Langford?

[Slugfester]

Langford?

I had already realized I could not include him but then absent mindedly did anyway. Thanks for catching that. I will think of someone else.

[Slugfester]

Langford?

OK, I fixed that. Top choice just edged out Fighting Harada and Pancho Villa.

[JAB5239]

Greb
Robinson
Armstrong
Charles
Pep
R. Leonard
Ross
Walker
Moore
B. Leonard

[DeeMoney]

This is a right now, while at work, off the head list. May make some tweaks later:

Ali
Armstrong
B. Leonard
Charles
Greb
Hagler
Louis
RJJ
SRL
SRR

A name I didn't include, and havent seen yet, but think needs to be in the convo, is Floyd. Whether you like him or not, in the ring he was good enough to get a mention in the discussion.

[Willow The Wisp]

Langford?

Canadian