Who rates higher, Hagler or Monzon?

[Willie Pep 229]

Monzon UD (close)

In a fight that Monzon never lets become a brawl; a fight that never reaches its expectation of excitement.

No Hagler-Hearns

[Silence]

Hagler of course. Monzon was unskilled flat footed slow hypejob with poor resume.

I rank Robinson higher than him at 160 as well.

[mrbig1]

Hagler of course. Monzon was unskilled flat footed slow hypejob with poor resume.

I rank Robinson higher than him at 160 as well.

[markusmod]

Monzon UD (close)

In a fight that Monzon never lets become a brawl; a fight that never reaches its expectation of excitement.

No Hagler-Hearns

Exactly how I see it.

[QueensburyRules]

Hagler of course. Monzon was unskilled flat footed slow hypejob with poor resume.

I rank Robinson higher than him at 160 as well.

- - I reckon both would KO Bubber save he gonna duck'em...

[markusmod]

- - I reckon both would KO Bubber save he gonna duck'em...

You think so?

[DooGee#33]

Good objective points, but it should be noted that Hagler lost his first fights with both Monroe and Watts,and Briscoe was 35 years old when Hagler beat him.

True though the Watts fight was not a just decision. He did avenge both defeats.

[DooGee#33]

Hagler of course. Monzon was unskilled flat footed slow hypejob with poor resume.

I rank Robinson higher than him at 160 as well.

Both Hagler and Monzon had consistent uninterrupted title reigns. I would probably rank them as better Middleweight Champions than Sugar Ray but the best version of Robinson at Middleweight 1949-52 would IMO be too much for both of them.

[Ivich]

Both Hagler and Monzon had consistent uninterrupted title reigns. I would probably rank them as better Middleweight Champions than Sugar Ray but the best version of Robinson at Middleweight 1949-52 would IMO be too much for both of them.

I'd have no problem with anyone placing any of the 3 at the top.I'd probably put Greb there myself.

[QueensburyRules]

Hagler of course. Monzon was unskilled flat footed slow hypejob with poor resume.

I rank Robinson higher than him at 160 as well.

- - Shame Marv had 5 years overlap with Monzon yet never in position to challenge because he was too busy avenging his losses to journeymen.

Nobody cares what a growed man still stuck in 3rd grade thinks anyway.