Peter landed more meaningful punches..

[Truth]

I think Toney even stunned Peter once, I forgot what round.

[restless_438]

Peter's punches had more intent then Toney's.

this is very close to the ******est thing i've ever read on these boards..

OHH... it all makes sense now... Peter's punches "intended" more than James', regardless of the fact that more than half never touched him..

okay, yeah, Peter did reserve the win.. lol

and yeah Truth, i mentioned that in another thread that the fact the Toney was actually able to make Peter stumble speaks volumes about this fight

[Smokin']

this is very close to the ******est thing i've ever read on these boards..

OHH... it all makes sense now... Peter's punches "intended" more than James', regardless of the fact that more than half never touched him..

okay, yeah, Peter did reserve the win.. lol

and yeah Truth, i mentioned that in another thread that the fact the Toney was actually able to make Peter stumble speaks volumes about this fight

Alright nuthugger. Notice how you're wrong on basically every fight because all you do is cheerlead your 'favorite' fighters. Suck it up. You were wrong like usual. Here's a bottle

[Kball15]

I had it for Peter close but wouldn't have blinked if Toney had gotten the decision. James was stung and even wobbled a lot more in these twelve rounds than I can recall since the RJJ bout, and while he may have landed more than Peter, his shots did virtually nothing. NOTHING!

a bloody nose, cut up mouth, and swollen eyes DEFINETLY shows how toney's punches didnt have an effect on peter

lol

toney was virtually unharmed by peters extreme power, why? because there wasnt a punch, not a single power punch from peter, that landed flush of toneys face! where did it land? on the back of his head every time. thats how he got hurt in the early round, and everytime after that.

jeez, how u can justify this decision is rediculous

and how u can justify 2 judges scoring the fight 116-111 is rediculous. it was a very close fight, but it was very clear who won that fight.

[Smokin']

I'm not justifying some of the judges scores. They are rediculous. Peter did win the fight, though. Peter landed the bigger harder shots that moved Toney around. Toney landed more shots but they weren't hard shots. They were jabs and this is pro boxing where the more damaging shots are supposed to mean more.

[restless_438]

Alright nuthugger. Notice how you're wrong on basically every fight because all you do is cheerlead your 'favorite' fighters. Suck it up. You were wrong like usual. Here's a bottle

It's more like the complete opposite playa.. your a Peter nuthugger that can't imagine him getting out-boxed.. you were wrong and blind.. You keep the bottle, you need it, . Let the grownups talk about the fight while you go play somewhere

[Smokin']

Let me ask you fools a question. WHo won these fights? The puncher or the swarmer/volume puncher:
Winky - Taylor
Winky - Soliman
Toney - Peter

...and so on. The puncher is winning lately which is exactly why I usually choose a puncher when I am betting money on a fight now.

[Smokin']

It's more like the complete opposite playa.. your a Peter nuthugger that can't imagine him getting out-boxed.. you were wrong and blind.. You keep the bottle, you need it, . Let the grownups talk about the fight while you go play somewhere

At least I'm not wrong about just about every fight like you are. Blind nuthugger.

[Kball15]

Let me ask you fools a question. WHo won these fights? The puncher or the swarmer/volume puncher:
Winky - Taylor
Winky - Soliman
Toney - Peter

...and so on. The puncher is winning lately which is exactly why I usually choose a puncher when I am betting money on a fight now.

winky was semi-semi-semi-robbed in the taylor fight (i had it a draw, but i could only see wright winning, and not taylor) and wright was the volume puncher who was pressing the action, taylor was the puncher...

[restless_438]

Let me ask you fools a question. WHo won these fights? The puncher or the swarmer/volume puncher:
Winky - Taylor
Winky - Soliman
Toney - Peter

...and so on. The puncher is winning lately which is exactly why I usually choose a puncher when I am betting money on a fight now.

and about your last sentence there..
Even if thats the case, that doesn't make it right

Listen, if you want to give a fighter a win because he had 3 or 4 flurries in a 12 round fight at most, you go ahead if it makes you happy..