Grade a fighter day 15: What grade do you give Andre Ward?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • daggum
    All time great
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Feb 2008
    • 43762
    • 4,684
    • 3
    • 166,270

    #21
    he wasnt a very good boxer at all. why do you think he always used illegal tactics? he didnt do that vs the bums he fought. he was a political creation but an A+ political creation!

    Comment

    • Boxing-1013
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Sep 2017
      • 6988
      • 1,098
      • 2,619
      • 57,573

      #22
      I'd give him a B. He was tough and smart in there, but honestly I think if he had a different promoter etc, he would have about 5 or so blemishes (loss/draw/DQ) on his record. He only really had like 10 legit fights in his career as well. I just never saw elite skills from him in any fight vs similar level opponents.

      Everything became murky and mucked up in those fights. He would often get away with 'fouls', with most rounds still being close, and all the while getting 90% of the close rounds on the official cards.

      He was 5-0 vs Kov1/2, Barrera, Bika and Kessler. With a different/more neutral ref and/or judges in those fights, he could easily be something like 2-2-1 in those 5. His best legit win is a 7-5 win at home over Froch. A good win but yeah with everything else about him, I've never really understood the appeal as a 'great boxer'. Tribalism is a hell of a thing I suppose.

      Comment

      • lolpz
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jun 2011
        • 2694
        • 148
        • 40
        • 42,305

        #23
        He was a first ballot hall of famer for a reason...

        I mean literally right behind pac and floyd this generation overall.

        What else needs to be said? A lot of people in this thread are really not being honest with themselves...Ward is better then every fighter that has been given an A+ so far, hands down.

        Comment

        • Boxing-1013
          Undisputed Champion
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Sep 2017
          • 6988
          • 1,098
          • 2,619
          • 57,573

          #24
          Originally posted by lolpz
          He was a first ballot hall of famer for a reason...

          I mean literally right behind pac and floyd this generation overall.

          What else needs to be said? A lot of people in this thread are really not being honest with themselves...Ward is better then every fighter that has been given an A+ so far, hands down.
          The main reason being he was American, and was marketed and promoted as 'the guy'.

          I think your comment and some of his 'grades' here prove why he was given special status.

          He was always going to be more marketable than a similarly skilled fighter from a different country. As a result he benefitted from a lot of breaks.

          He was a tough smart fighter, but if you don't see the breaks he got, I mean idk what to say. There are still some people who swear he dominated guys like Bika and Barrera, and I'm here to tell you that never happened.

          Comment

          • lolpz
            Undisputed Champion
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Jun 2011
            • 2694
            • 148
            • 40
            • 42,305

            #25
            Originally posted by Boxing-1013
            The main reason being he was American, and was marketed and promoted as 'the guy'.

            I think your comment and some of his 'grades' here prove why he was given special status.

            He was always going to be more marketable than a similarly skilled fighter from a different country. As a result he benefitted from a lot of breaks.

            He was a tough smart fighter, but if you don't see the breaks he got, I mean idk what to say. There are still some people who swear he dominated guys like Bika and Barrera, and I'm here to tell you that never happened.
            Won a gold medal in a class he had to eat into in order to make weight at the olympics...yes “special break.”

            Cleared out killers at 168 and took on the boogeyman at 175. Took on top guy after top guy and handled em...

            You literally went full retard.

            Comment

            • Boxing-1013
              Undisputed Champion
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Sep 2017
              • 6988
              • 1,098
              • 2,619
              • 57,573

              #26
              Originally posted by lolpz
              Won a gold medal in a class he had to eat into in order to make weight at the olympics...yes “special break.”

              Cleared out killers at 168 and took on the boogeyman at 175. Took on top guy after top guy and handled em...

              You literally went full retard.
              Can't comment on his amateur accolades. Never saw him fight there. In the pros he was definitely a guy who could win clean against average competition, which is mostly what the ams are. He did have a nice 'story' to him in the ams as well which probably helped him there.

              Killers at 168? Come on man. And we all know what happened in the Kov fights, as I mentioned prior. Overhyping Ward is just weird. Like I watched all his big fights.

              As I said, he had about 10 real fights as a pro. And if he had different judges/refs, he could have a blemish (loss/draw/DQ) in half of those.

              What's there to really get excited about?

              Comment

              • GrandpaBernard
                Banned
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • May 2010
                • 17156
                • 4,480
                • 2,947
                • 114,399

                #27
                On the shallow end of great

                An excellent fighter

                I wasn’t ever excited to see him fight though. He had that Mikey Garcia effect

                Comment

                • Bandman
                  Banned
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Oct 2015
                  • 3205
                  • 291
                  • 21
                  • 90,715

                  #28
                  Missed the poll. but A+ for me

                  Comment

                  • elfag
                    Alpha fäggot
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Jan 2008
                    • 15633
                    • 3,492
                    • 302
                    • 65,929

                    #29
                    he was good with the super 6, thought he was going to be something bigger, an atg

                    then he stopped fighting anyone with a pulse.

                    beat a drained chad dawson

                    thought he was gifted kov 1 and won kov 2 with a literal 5 punch combination to the balls, kov looks to the ref like ok we starting my 5 minutes now right? ref looks at him and says no bud you were just knocked out.

                    Comment

                    • lolpz
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Jun 2011
                      • 2694
                      • 148
                      • 40
                      • 42,305

                      #30
                      Originally posted by Boxing-1013
                      Can't comment on his amateur accolades. Never saw him fight there. In the pros he was definitely a guy who could win clean against average competition, which is mostly what the ams are. He did have a nice 'story' to him in the ams as well which probably helped him there.

                      Killers at 168? Come on man. And we all know what happened in the Kov fights, as I mentioned prior. Overhyping Ward is just weird. Like I watched all his big fights.

                      As I said, he had about 10 real fights as a pro. And if he had different judges/refs, he could have a blemish (loss/draw/DQ) in half of those.

                      What's there to really get excited about?
                      You're just a hater, nothing more to it really.

                      When you fail to give someone credit who clearly deserves it, your true colors show.

                      Maybe you didn't think he was that great stylistically, but to refuse to acknowledge what he did by calling all his competition average and claiming the amateurs is a walk in the park let's me know everything I need when you assess Ward and his career. Maybe it didn't look that special, but he always got the job done and very convincingly, against the best in the world consistently since age 10. To me it seems you didn't fancy the way in which he got it done, but he got it done nonetheless.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP