What's wrong with my P4P list?

[ShaneMosleySr]

De La Hoya was the top dog in 2008 when Floyd Mayweather moved up to fight him.

It didn’t mean De La Hoya was the number one p4p fighter.

but Pac is currently the top dog. both Spence and Bud want him.. not just because he's a name but a beltholder and a credible champ too. Thurman was in great shape and elite form so full credit is deserved.

[Bandman]

No inoue at all is extremely questionable he's better than most if not all the people on that list (all is a heavy debate). His resume is outstanding, he's heavily dominant as well. Once that's addressed you can look back, but Pac.... is not #1 by any stretch imo.

Ok Inoue is getting a lot of love here. but who has he beat? didn't he have to go to hell n back to beat a washed Nonito? im just saying..

[Bandman]

De La Hoya was the top dog in 2008 when Floyd Mayweather moved up to fight him.

It didn’t mean De La Hoya was the number one p4p fighter.

Oscar was not top dog in 2008. not even close. he had just beat Mayorga a year prior. Keef had wins vs Danny Garcia and Shawn Porter. undefeated and top 3 easly at 147. that's top dog status.

[Combat Talk Radio]

There's no sensible reason for Crawford to be above Spence. None.

[Bandman]

What's not wrong with it?

Speak on it son.

[Bandman]

There's no sensible reason for Crawford to be above Spence. None.

1. Postol (boogeyman)
2. Undisputed
3. Beat the man who beat the man

[Combat Talk Radio]

1. Postol (boogeyman)
2. Undisputed
3. Beat the man who beat the man

So 2 of those happened almost a decade ago.

We can't keep letting fighters feast on old accomplishments when others are beating Top 5 welterweights ( aka the CURRENT weight class ) back-to-back in the span of a year.

[ShaneMosleySr]

De La Hoya was the top dog.

He was the biggest non heavyweight draw in the entire sport at the time.

His win over Mayorga was for a title at 154. Mayorga was the former undisputed champion at 147 and a two division champion. That’s totally comparable to Garcia or Porter.

Oscar was not top dog in 2008. not even close. he had just beat Mayorga a year prior. Keef had wins vs Danny Garcia and Shawn Porter. undefeated and top 3 easly at 147. that's top dog status.