What's wrong with my P4P list?

[Bandman]

1. Pacquiao (resume wise he's head and shoulders above. just beat a top dog Thurman as an old man underdog. Current beltholder.)

2. Canelo (second best resume. beat supposed "ducked" opponents like Lara and GGG. the real Mr. 160-175)

3. Crawford (undisputed. beat supposed "ducked" opponent like Postol. beat the man who beat the man at 147.)

4. Usyk (undisputed. Greatest CW ever next to Evander.)

5. Spence (best resume of top dogs at 147. gave Danny Garcia his clearest loss to date. ducked by Thurman for 4+ years. won his belt on enemy territory.)

6. Fury (lineal champ. destroyed Wilder.)

7. Teofimo (whooped on ESPN's greatest boxer ever Lomachenko as a green fighter.)

8. AJ (best resume at heavyweight. 2-time world champ.)

9. Jermall (top dog at 154. nobody beats him.)

10. Loma (still top ten based on resume.)

[Quercusalba]

You need to make room for...

Naoya 'The Monster' Inoue

[lopetego]

1. Pacquiao (resume wise he's head and shoulders above. just beat a top dog Thurman as an old man underdog. Current beltholder.)

2. Canelo (second best resume. beat supposed "ducked" opponents like Lara and GGG. the real Mr. 160-175)

3. Crawford (undisputed. beat supposed "ducked" opponent like Postol. beat the man who beat the man at 147.)

4. Usyk (undisputed. Greatest CW ever next to Evander.)

5. Spence (best resume of top dogs at 147. gave Danny Garcia his clearest loss to date. ducked by Thurman for 4+ years. won his belt on enemy territory.)

6. Fury (lineal champ. destroyed Wilder.)

7. Teofimo (whooped on ESPN's greatest boxer ever Lomachenko as a green fighter.)

8. AJ (best resume at heavyweight. 2-time world champ.)

9. Jermall (top dog at 154. nobody beats him.)

10. Loma (still top ten based on resume.)

Pacquiao is a ghost from the past era.

We all know he's in borrowed time, he shouldn't be in the top spot. Maybe at the bottom of the list

Canelo is p4p #1

Loma should be higher, Crawford's cherrypicking ass should be lower, Spence should be lower

Inoue should be on the list

[ShaneMosleySr]

P4P is less about resumes and more about dominance.

Pacquiao hasn’t been dominant recently. He’s not the best boxer in the world.

The best boxer in the world outclasses him.

I have the same opinion of Canelo, many don’t.

[Marchegiano]

1. Pacquiao (resume wise he's head and shoulders above. just beat a top dog Thurman as an old man underdog. Current beltholder.)

2. Canelo (second best resume. beat supposed "ducked" opponents like Lara and GGG. the real Mr. 160-175)

3. Crawford (undisputed. beat supposed "ducked" opponent like Postol. beat the man who beat the man at 147.)

4. Usyk (undisputed. Greatest CW ever next to Evander.)

5. Spence (best resume of top dogs at 147. gave Danny Garcia his clearest loss to date. ducked by Thurman for 4+ years. won his belt on enemy territory.)

6. Fury (lineal champ. destroyed Wilder.)

7. Teofimo (whooped on ESPN's greatest boxer ever Lomachenko as a green fighter.)

8. AJ (best resume at heavyweight. 2-time world champ.)

9. Jermall (top dog at 154. nobody beats him.)

10. Loma (still top ten based on resume.)

****ing gorgeous man. Love that you gave explanations too.

P4P is less about resumes and more about dominance.

Pacquiao hasn’t been dominant recently. He’s not the best boxer in the world.

The best boxer in the world outclasses him.

I have the same opinion of Canelo, many don’t.

I'm not prompting to argue, I won't "teach" you anything, I'm just curious; what makes you say p4p is about dominance? Where did you get that?

[Dakuwaqa]

I would have Spence above Crawford. He undoubtedly has a better record. But yeah good list bro

[The Big Dunn]

1. Pacquiao (resume wise he's head and shoulders above. just beat a top dog Thurman as an old man underdog. Current beltholder.)

2. Canelo (second best resume. beat supposed "ducked" opponents like Lara and GGG. the real Mr. 160-175)

3. Crawford (undisputed. beat supposed "ducked" opponent like Postol. beat the man who beat the man at 147.)

4. Usyk (undisputed. Greatest CW ever next to Evander.)

5. Spence (best resume of top dogs at 147. gave Danny Garcia his clearest loss to date. ducked by Thurman for 4+ years. won his belt on enemy territory.)

6. Fury (lineal champ. destroyed Wilder.)

7. Teofimo (whooped on ESPN's greatest boxer ever Lomachenko as a green fighter.)

8. AJ (best resume at heavyweight. 2-time world champ.)

9. Jermall (top dog at 154. nobody beats him.)

10. Loma (still top ten based on resume.)

What is wrong? #1, No Inoue, and #8.

[Ochoa780]

I would have Spence above Crawford. He undoubtedly has a better record. But yeah good list bro

Yea. I could argue teo being higher with his last two wins

And crawford isnt undisputed

[daggum]

you wrote jermall but its jermell who fights at 154 and his resume isnt that good. he went 1-1 against an unranked guy and then beat a one win wonder guy who ko'd mr glass williams but besides that he was ko'd by gallimore, draw with mark hernandez? and a split decision vs cota? very opportunistic matchmaking there

[ralex]

It’s not a bad list.

Canelo is #1 to me because currently he’s better than Pac. Pac of course has a better resume but at this point he’s not a better fighter.