my top 5 active p4p

[ben41193]

Hahahaha, I had to stop after this. Seriously? The best defensein boxing right now by far and possibly all time? Have you ever heard of fighters such as Willie Pep, Sugar Ray Robinson, "Sweet Pea" Whitaker, Roy Jones, Jr., Sugar Ray Leonard, and Floyd Mayweather, Jr.? Every single one of these boxers mentioned has a better defense than Winky. Hell, Willie Pep is the only boxer in history credited with winning a round in which he never threw a punch. How's that for defense?

Fighting in the peek-a-boo style doesn't equate great defense. Those that can evade punches or roll with them do a much better job than those that can block them (like Winky). Fighters like Roy Jones, Jr. or Bernard Hopkins would've eaten Winky's "defense" for lunch.

Also, you have him at #1 yet the man who beat P4P # 1 and fought to a draw with #2 is not on your list. Taylor beat Bernard Hopkins TWICE and had Winky running scared in the last round of their fight. How can you have Winky at #1?

BTW, anyone who beats Winky will not look good, but they'll have the W, which is what matters.

Okay i guess you make a good point with your defense thing. Maybe he doesnt have the best of all time but he has to have the best right now. ( Also yes i have heard of those fighers.)

And as far a jermaign taylor goes. You are right. I had him at number six but you make a good point. Ill take marco antonio berrera down to 6 and put jermaighn taylor at number 3 and put pbf at number 4.

So my new list is
1. winky wright
2. Pacman
3. Jermaign taylor
4. pbf
5. b-hop

Is this one any better?

[PATO 1]

what top fighter is floyd duckin


not mosley , not hatton, not cotto , not de la hoya , dont tell me Margarito he aint a big name

[PATO 1]

btw why are you changin your list to satisfy other people


dumb thread dumb pbf comments dumb p4p list

[ben41193]

what top fighter is floyd duckin


not mosley , not hatton, not cotto , not de la hoya , dont tell me Margarito he aint a big name

Exactly my point margorito isnt a big name. Margarito is no way near as good as the big name in his weight class and floyed is ducking him. What do you think he is gonna do when he does have to fight the big names? He is gonna duck them and if he does fight he is gonna get torn apart.

[ben41193]

btw why are you changin your list to satisfy other people


dumb thread dumb pbf comments dumb p4p list

No im not changing it to satisfy other people im changing it because people are maaking good points and im realizing that it`s wrong so i change it.

[PATO 1]

Exactly my point margorito isnt a big name. Margarito is no way near as good as the big name in his weight class and floyed is ducking him. What do you think he is gonna do when he does have to fight the big names? He is gonna duck them and if he does fight he is gonna get torn apart.

LOL like genaro hernandez, angel manfredy, gregorio vargas, Diego Corrales,Jose Luis Castillo, Jesus Chavez

come on man so your saying he is duckin mosley,cotto,hatton,oscar etc

[Jimislash]

1. PBF (Not a Floyd fan)
2. Winky
3. Jermain
4. Pacman
5. Roy Jones Jr.











...ok, just kidding on 5.

5. MAB

[ben41193]

LOL like genaro hernandez, angel manfredy, gregorio vargas, Diego Corrales,Jose Luis Castillo, Jesus Chavez

come on man so your saying he is duckin mosley,cotto,hatton,oscar etc

Okay im just getiing embarassed at this point.

Okay lets just pretend he isnt ducking anybody. what im trying to say is When he starts fighting people like shane mosly and oscar de lahoya he is gonna start to lose a lot more. Sugar shane mosly will tear mayweather apart , daylahoya will tear him apart, and if floyed would go back down ill bet even pacman would beat him.floyed is a p4p fighter but when he starts fighting other p4p fighters it will be painfully clear that he is not number 1.

[PATO 1]

Okay im just getiing embarassed at this point.

Okay lets just pretend he isnt ducking anybody. what im trying to say is When he starts fighting people like shane mosly and oscar de lahoya he is gonna start to lose a lot more. Sugar shane mosly will tear mayweather apart , daylahoya will tear him apart, and if floyed would go back down ill bet even pacman would beat him.floyed is a p4p fighter but when he starts fighting other p4p fighters it will be painfully clear that he is not number 1.

yep you are and that post didnt help either

[ben41193]

yep you are and that post didnt help either

But do u realy think mayweather can beat mosly and them?