Name the fights that you think Floyd Mayweather lost

[Boxxymcboxface]

I thought both Castillo and Maidana beat him in their first fights. I thought Oscar fought him to a draw.

[IronDanHamza]

Only Maidana 1. He definitely lost that fight.

I ask this because I respect your opinion, how can you say he “definitely” lost that fight?

[Mr. 29K]

Castillo
De La Hoya
Maidana 1


The *** thugs will disagree doe.

[Luilun]

Castillo 1 Madaina 1 He did not do enough to beat the Champ against Delahoya Lost to Zab Judah because Roger enter the ring to put a choke hold on Zab rules state if a cornerman enters the ring you lose. Pacquiao fight he just held and ran even his own dad said you're fighting scared should have lost that fight as well

[The D3vil]

Just Castillo

[4truth]

Castillo 1 was a robbery.

I've got no real issue with any other fight, Maidana 1 was a close fight but I've no real problem with the decision. Oscar should have won but he didn't, he gave it away in the last 1/2 of the fight.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

I’m no fan of Floyd but honestly none.

Never scored a fight against him.

I felt JLC, Oscar and Maidana all pushed him close but I still had him winning at least 7 rounds in each.

[R-Hand Southpaw]

Top of the head

Castillo 1
Maidaina 1
OLDH

Castillo 1 I thought he clearly lost. It was a bad night for Floyd and he should have gotten the L.

Maidaina was a close fight I felt could have gone either way but Maidaina imo outworked Floyd for the majority and Floyd came on too late.

How do you know Floyd lost against OLDH or it was too close for Floyds comfort? Floyd retired so he didnt have to fight him again.

A lot of people are pretty much agreement here.

I also think the Pac fight was a lot closer than people imagine it was too. If I recall Mayweather did absolutely nothing the last 2-3 rounds just show boating against Pac. He knew he would win regardless and didnt even fight. Hence why the fight was absolute garbage.

Easy to win when you know if you look good enough and make it to score cards you're virtually guaranteed a win.

The only guy that doesn't work against is Canelo but for the exact same reasons.

[Marchegiano]

None, Floyd deserves his 0.

[paulf]

I ask this because I respect your opinion, how can you say he “definitely” lost that fight?

I mean I'm just expressing my opinion as we all are; I've watched it twice, don't remember my score but I try to score as judges do (very close rounds to the champ/house fighter) and I couldn't see how one could score it for Floyd. To me, that was a Maidana W.

Castillo on the other hand; I scored for Floyd, but that fight had so many close rounds that a variety of scores are reasonable.