Floyd's resume.

[MikeyMike100]

I think having never won a fight where he was a clear underdog is what keeps Floyd from ever being mentioned as the GOAT. Hard to be the greatest when you only win fights you're supposed to win.

He never had that Ali vs. Liston/Foreman fight or Leonard vs. Hagler.

Top fighter of a generation and greatest boxing businessman all-time for sure.

Goat or near goat? Naw.

He was the underdog vs Corales

[MikeyMike100]

I think most of Floyd's later wins as a megastar were against guys coming off their own big wins. Baldomir was the lineal champ, Hatton was undefeated, Mosely wrecked the undefeated Margarito, Ortiz was in FOY against Berto, Cotto got his revenge off Margarito, Guerrero was on a hot streak, Alvarez had just unified with Trout, and Maidana had just beaten Broner. Oscar and Manny weren't on hot streaks but were megastars in their own right. The only fights where the opponents and fight weren't 'hot' was probably the Judah, Berto, and Marquez.

Exactly the only major cherry pick fights were the Marquez one because he was coming up so much in weight and his last fight vs Berto because he wanted an easier fight to close out his career

[djtmal]

Its not a sense of being over protective. It's wondering why people refusing to fight him is held against his resume. It's also wondering why he seems to be the only fighter whose resume is evaluated by who he didn't fight rather than who he did fight.

Floyd fans just want the same criteria used to analyze his resume as we do with every other fighter. I don't think that is too much to ask.

Nobody refused to fight him. That is just an excuse you boys use because holding him accountable for his actions is not in your best interest.

[The Big Dunn]

Nah it’s definitely over protective, whenever a guy makes a Floyd thread the same people always jump straight down their throat, like it’s illegal to question anything regarding Floyd to some people.

I get some anti-Mayweather guys constantly troll and stuff but some guys just wanna discuss his career objectively.

There surely is no question he is a 1st ballot HOF'er and an ATG. For boxers, that is only achieved through the resume .Floyd's resume has made him a 1st ballot HOF'er and THE headliner in a HOF class that will feature Wlad and Ward, plus the guys from last year. As such, there seems to be no need to discuss his resume given these facts.

Further, it defies anyone's intelligence to reasonably understand how anyone with an account on this site, and thus considered a die hard fan, would need to discuss this "objectively" for at least the 100th time. The only people who seem to want to "objectively" discuss it are people who use a different standard to analyze resumes.

[The Big Dunn]

Nobody refused to fight him. That is just an excuse you boys use because holding him accountable for his actions is not in your best interest.

It has been documented that ODH, Shane and Manny refused to fight him. You're never honest about it so I don't expect you to be now.

Please just go back to sucking off blowblow. It's the only real talent or skill you have.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

There surely is no question he is a 1st ballot HOF'er and an ATG. For boxers, that is only achieved through the resume .Floyd's resume has made him a 1st ballot HOF'er and THE headliner in a HOF class that will feature Wlad and Ward, plus the guys from last year. As such, there seems to be no need to discuss his resume given these facts.

Further, it defies anyone's intelligence to reasonably understand how anyone with an account on this site, and thus considered a die hard fan, would need to discuss this "objectively" for at least the 100th time. The only people who seem to want to "objectively" discuss it are people who use a different standard to analyze resumes.

That’s no reason not to debate it though. It’s a great resume but it could have been even better.

We still question Robinson, Leonard, Armstrong, Roy etc. There’s no reason not to question Floyd too as long as it’s objective.

[blowblow]

It has been documented that ODH, Shane and Manny refused to fight him. You're never honest about it so I don't expect you to be now.

Please just go back to sucking off blowblow. It's the only real talent or skill you have.

the real fact is floyd ducked pacquaio and that's the truth.. don't come by here telling lies and it doesn't make you look good.. ODH and mosley might refused to fight floyd but pac? don't be delusional if he ducked the glass chin khan what more if its the best pac? we all know floyd ducked 2009 pac after watching cotto got face-wrecked.

you can suck my dck if you want coz that's your forte.

[blowblow]

That’s no reason not to debate it though. It’s a great resume but it could have been even better.

We still question Robinson, Leonard, Armstrong, Roy etc. There’s no reason not to question Floyd too as long as it’s objective.

no wonder for a floyd die hard fan to look it that way.. like i said, for them floyd is their god, hero, no sin, perfect and unquestionable.. too much love for floyd here.. right the big dummb?

[blowblow]

There surely is no question he is a 1st ballot HOF'er and an ATG. For boxers, that is only achieved through the resume .Floyd's resume has made him a 1st ballot HOF'er and THE headliner in a HOF class that will feature Wlad and Ward, plus the guys from last year. As such, there seems to be no need to discuss his resume given these facts.

Further, it defies anyone's intelligence to reasonably understand how anyone with an account on this site, and thus considered a die hard fan, would need to discuss this "objectively" for at least the 100th time. The only people who seem to want to "objectively" discuss it are people who use a different standard to analyze resumes.

the resume that was made from cherry pickings plus every advantages he can buy lol

[Roadblock]

the resume that was made from cherry pickings plus every advantages he can buy lol

Why you talking about Manny .