The Fighter of the First Two Decades of the 21st Century!

[The Big Dunn]

I didn’t see Floyd Mayweather move up to cruiserweight and lose a disputed decision either.

Why would you need to see him move up to cruiserweight?

I mean don’t be one of those dude so desperate to make manny better that you equate moving up 4 lbs with 10-15 lbs.

Just cut the BS and put the resumes side by side.

[Roadblock]

Pacquiao, because Pacquiao defeated prime ATG's at their best weight class on his resume while Floyd doesn't even have a prime A-level fighter in his resume.

Pacquiao lasted longer, had fought better competition, and had beaten Prime Fighters and especially fought through the entire 2 decades and kept on achieving things that had never been achieved, the first man to become a 7 and 8 division champion while being also the first man to become a lineal champion at 5 different weight classes while also being the Oldest welterweight champion in history, out achieving his contemporary of Floyd and Mosley by 2 years (Floyd and Mosley was respectively the oldest welterweight champions in the world but Pacquiao broke that record at 40.) and Pacquiao is the first fighter in the entire history of boxing to be a champion in 4 different decades out lasting all his fellow all time greats, that is just unheard of.

Floyd Mayweather would have been the greatest of his generation had he fought Prime fighters like Paul Williams, Prime Manny, Prime Margarito, but he settled waiting them out till they are out of the picture.

Floyd's best win this decade is a recently KO'ed Pacquiao, Canelo is a good win, but Floyd draining Canelo to death at 152 hurts his win.

So Pacquiao for me, on the basis that Pacquiao achieved more than Floyd and fought better competition, there's no better win than a Prime Marco Antonio Barrera who was on a tear coming off with the wins of Hamed, Ayala, Kelly, Morales etc. etc.

That is why, Pacquiao is the greatest of his generation IMO.

A joke, Manny beat prime ATGs at their best weight, what a crock of horse sht ! and then you mention Floyds only CW .

Gee you people a so delusional .

[BoomBapTrap]

You fanboys are pathetic man...

I’d take Manny over Floyd any day but in reality Floyd easily had the better 2010’s.

Floyd’s dominant wins over Canelo and Pacquiao surpass anything on Pacs resume in the 2010’s. Add to that Mosley, Guerrero who were both ranked inside the top 10 P4P at the time Floyd beat them. And then Cotto and Maidana x2.

Nah that’s a weak arse resume.

Maidana? U mean the guy Khan whooped right?
LMAO!!! And Floyd fought him twice! Hahahaha

Neither Bradley nor Thurman got whooped by Khan, that doesn’t say much about beating Maidana, whom Floyd actually lost to.

Floyd’s resume for 2010’s smells like hot arse.
Manny’s is much better, much more thorough.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Nah that’s a weak arse resume.

Maidana? U mean the guy Khan whooped right?
LMAO!!! And Floyd fought him twice! Hahahaha

Neither Bradley nor Thurman got whooped by Khan, that doesn’t say much about beating Maidana, whom Floyd actually lost to.

Floyd’s resume for 2010’s smells like hot arse.
Manny’s is much better, much more thorough.

You clearly haven’t watched Maidana-Khan.

You listed Algieri FFS😂😂

You also listed Broner who literally got whooped by Maidana😂😂

I think you’re forgetting Pac’s 2010’s resume also featured losses to Marquez, Bradley, Horn and Mayweather.

I’m a Pacquiao fan and can’t stand Floyd, but Mayweather evidently had a better 2010-19. Only a delusional fanboy would disagree.

[MDPopescu]

... Manny should have simply beaten Floyd in the ring...

... which he didn't...

[ShaneMosleySr]

We’re doing it by weight and not weight class?

Mayweather moved up in weight 24 pounds in his career.

Pacquiao moved up 42 pounds in his career.

So cruiserweight was overstating it. I never saw Mayweather lose a fight at 175.

Why would you need to see him move up to cruiserweight?

I mean don’t be one of those dude so desperate to make manny better that you equate moving up 4 lbs with 10-15 lbs.

Just cut the BS and put the resumes side by side.

[The Big Dunn]

We’re doing it by weight and not weight class?

Mayweather moved up in weight 24 pounds in his career.

Pacquiao moved up 42 pounds in his career.

So cruiserweight was overstating it. I never saw Mayweather lose a fight at 175.

Moving up 42 lbs when you come in as a teenager isn't surprising. You are still growing and continue to grow until you are 21. Someone that starts his career at age 20 isn't going to grow as much.

You wouldn't need to see him fight at 175 either because he took care of himself. He didn't blow up in weight like Duran or Broner in between fights.

Just cut the BS and put the resumes side by side.

[dibzvincent143]

Floyd’s best win against an absolute prime fighter is Corrales.

Pacquiao was against barrera.

[The Big Dunn]

Floyd’s best win against an absolute prime fighter is Corrales.

Pacquiao was against barrera.

You know what is weird, Manny is considered a bad win for Floyd because he had been through wars. Yet Barrera, who had also been through wars, is seen as absolute prime.

[famicommander]

Floyd's wins:
Berto
Pacquiao
Maidana twice
Canelo
Guerrero
Cotto
Ortiz
Mosley
Marquez
Hatton
De La Hoya
Baldomir
Judah
Mitchell
Gatti
Bruseles
Corley
N'Dou
Sosa
Castillo twice
Chavez
Hernandez
Corrales
Augustus
Vargas

Nobody else even deserves consideration. Pac had 5 losses and 2 draws in the same time span.