Who wins: the Pacquiao that beat Margarito vs the Canelo that lost to Mayweather?

[-Kev-]

Lol I can't think of that fight because I just can't ever see it happen. Pacquiao is a legend and all, better than a future Hall of Famer, he's an ATG. But he would've never stepped in the ring with 154 pound Canelo even at a catchweight of 150lbs, let alone a catchweight of 152. I can't have a verdict for that fantasy fight.

[IceTrayDaGang]

pac whoops on that version of canelo.

[4truth]

Canelo at 152 would have been no fight at all. Canelo at 155 would have been a war, probably Canelo takes that.

[Monzon99]

Canelo was bribed to lose to Mayweather, Haymon needed a big name for the SHowtime contract and Espinoza sold out Canelo and Oscar. Oscar didn't even show up to see the fight, nor did JC Chavez Sr. Biggest fight in Mexico's history was a fix for Floyd.

[South Champion]

Canelo was bribed to lose to Mayweather, Haymon needed a big name for the SHowtime contract and Espinoza sold out Canelo and Oscar. Oscar didn't even show up to see the fight, nor did JC Chavez Sr. Biggest fight in Mexico's history was a fix for Floyd.

Do you think the Canelo-Kovalev fight was fixed too?

[hugh grant]

Did you see Pac v cott o and nel o v cotto? Pac dealt with cott o like nel o would loved to.
Pac beats the green kid.
But Pac started 2 or 3 divisions below floyd. There's no reason why Pac should be fighting so many Floyd opponents and common opponents with floyd. Floyd only da red fight with a cw, so Pac shouldn't be fighting nelo at all

[HarvardBlue]

****** thread. Pac would TKO that Green Nelo in 8 rounds.

During that time, every opponent Mayweather beat, PAC SLAUGHTERED.

Margarito was a much harder hitting taller opponent then Green Nelo. PAC SLAUGHTERS GREEN NELO.

You must not have seen the JMM fights. And Canelo is a pretty good counter puncher also.

[elfag]

People forget that slow ass margarito still busted up pac, made him piss blood and ruptured his ear drums.

Canelo hits far harder, is far faster and far more skilled.

Mayweather made Canelo hit air all night, due to his superior defense.

23 year old Nelo stops Pacquaio.


Remember, JMM put Pacquaio out cold in a brutal knock out while Mayweather won every round.

[Legends456]

Pacquiao beat Margarito at Light Middleweight at a catchweight. Canelo lost to Mayweather at Light Middleweight at a catchweight.

Pacquiao started at Minimumweight, while Canelo just won a title at Light Heavyweight.

But if the Light Middleweight version of Pacquiao fought the version of Canelo that fought Mayweather, who would win?

Wow that’s a great hypothetical matchup.

That version of Pacquiao was really something else...
I honestly hope it wasn’t down to PED’s or something cause I love Pacquiao. There are very few boxers I feel that version of Pacquiao can’t beat at that weight. Needless to say, I think that version of Canelo loses via UD. I think that version of Pacquiao maybe gets a draw with Mayweather, or a close SD either way.

[KillaMane26]

****** thread. Pac would TKO that Green Nelo in 8 rounds.

During that time, every opponent Mayweather beat, PAC SLAUGHTERED.

Margarito was a much harder hitting taller opponent then Green Nelo. PAC SLAUGHTERS GREEN NELO.

Oh lord...

Manny wins. But Marg. Not a big puncher never has been he was just huge.

And Manny only KOed Hatton, Diaz so why wouldnt Canelo survive?

Manny outhustles Nelo but Nelo will make it competitive