Who wins: the Pacquiao that beat Margarito vs the Canelo that lost to Mayweather?

[Joe Beamish]

Pac tears up that version of Canelo.

Canelo learned, when you are the A side, you force opponents to fight at a weight that unfairly handicaps them.

[pasawayako]

Lol. That would be a total mismatch. Pac will annihilate and probably retire that version of canelo.

[bngsdad]

PAC won't knock him out but get a wide UD


A '10 Margarito vs a '13 Alvarez should be a better match up

[strykr619]

Canelo was bribed to lose to Mayweather, Haymon needed a big name for the SHowtime contract and Espinoza sold out Canelo and Oscar. Oscar didn't even show up to see the fight, nor did JC Chavez Sr. Biggest fight in Mexico's history was a fix for Floyd.

ROFL, Canelo got schooled by Mayweather and I can't even stand that guy.

[strykr619]

And Im saying a green 152 Canelo is miles ahead of a shot Margarito in the ring, Canelo would have stopped the Margarito that Manny beat, the size and speed would have come into it with Canelo vs Pac, he was not slow as molasses as Margarito was and Canelo always had fast straight punches and we know he has a granite chin, so to say a win is better or worse when a guy is shot and one reaching his best is called pulling the wool over youre own eyes.

Some of these matches without the asterisks attached would have different outcomes and so change history and the perception of what a fighter really is, match making is very powerful tool when you have an elite fighter.

LOL That version Pac would of broken Canelo's orbital bone. Just like he did to Marg.

[O Prophet]

People forget that slow ass margarito still busted up pac, made him piss blood and ruptured his ear drums

Made him piss blood? Were you creeping in Pac’s bathroom after the fight?

[Curtis Harper]

That Pac was very careful and wisely picked Margarito

The Nelo that lost to May would absolutely destroy ANY version of Pac.

[Curtis Harper]

Lol. That would be a total mismatch. Pac will annihilate and probably retire that version of canelo.

While I thought Pac should have won, he didn't come close to annihilating Horn

WW (NO CW) Cotto would kill Pac.
WW+ Nelo would do even more harm to Pac.

EDIT -
''SOME'' Pac fans truly are the stuff that clogs toilets and drainage pipes

[Legends456]

While I thought Pac should have won, he didn't come close to annihilating Horn

WW (NO CW) Cotto would kill Pac.
WW+ Nelo would do even more harm to Pac.

Pac fans truly are the stuff that clogs toilets and drainage pipes

What a RUDE thing to say!!

[Curtis Harper]

What a RUDE thing to say!!

?????