What constitutes a 'robbery'?

[aboutfkntime]

say this...

Yeah it's always a bit strange looking at how some score fights...and then you come across their other posts and they are big fans of the guy they have winning, or really hate the guy who they have losing...just coincidence I guess.

but then does this...

I honestly can't believe anyone would try and say Canelo won 5 clear rounds in the first fight...or the second fight...I can't find one clear round he won in either fight tbh...GGG's workrate and jab/scoring are just too consistent and Canelo got outlanded almost every round

... omg...

[GGG Gloveking]

Anything other than a KO.

Guarantee someone will be crying robbery.

[Curtis Harper]

I can't put it in words (so here are some words )

The best I could do is use some examples -

DLH vs Trinidad
Pac vs Horn
Pac vs Bradley 1
Pea vs Ramirez 1
DLH vs Mosley (1 or 2)
(victim is on the left)

When a guy is reduced to throwing, and maybe, landing 1 punch at a time.
When a guy resorts to dirty tactics hoping to cause a cut or fool judges into thinking dirty is ''effective aggression''.
When a guy is so thoroughly outclassed you just can't find rounds to give him.

Usually, when it's all tallied up, he who lands the most wins.
How can a guy who lands less win a fight ???
In what scenario, that doesn't have knock downs, can a guy who landed less punches win that fight ?!?!?

''Compubox (humans counting punches) DKSAB !!!''



Let that same person see his hero get robbed and see how fast they turn to punch stats to state their case -

''My guy OUTLANDED that guy 4 to 1 !!!! Straight up robbery !!!''

Judges who favor a certain style should be banned from judging. You don't score style unless it effective.

[uppercut510]

unreasonable boxing fans looking for a reason to complain

[Boxing_1013]

fk you're a knob

you are an absolute fkn moron... of the VERY highest order

will I just add that to your list... ?

I don't think you keep it very real my friend on boxing...so I will just give ya a thumbs up and wish ya well!

[Boxing_1013]

I can't put it in words (so here are some words )

The best I could do is use some examples -

DLH vs Trinidad
Pac vs Horn
Pac vs Bradley 1
Pea vs Ramirez 1
DLH vs Mosley (1 or 2)
(victim is on the left)

When a guy is reduced to throwing, and maybe, landing 1 punch at a time.
When a guy resorts to dirty tactics hoping to cause a cut or fool judges into thinking dirty is ''effective aggression''.
When a guy is so thoroughly outclassed you just can't find rounds to give him.

Usually, when it's all tallied up, he who lands the most wins.
How can a guy who lands less win a fight ???
In what scenario, that doesn't have knock downs, can a guy who landed less punches win that fight ?!?!?

''Compubox (humans counting punches) DKSAB !!!''



Let that same person see his hero get robbed and see how fast they turn to punch stats to state their case -

''My guy OUTLANDED that guy 4 to 1 !!!! Straight up robbery !!!''

Judges who favor a certain style should be banned from judging. You don't score style unless it effective.

Good post man...for the record, I only cite compubox when it more or less backs up what I see in the ring...which makes sense in a way...I think all compubox is, is two guys counting the punches, one for each guy...most of the time those guys get it about right, since that is all they are looking for...but sometimes they seem to miss a lot of the work that one of the guys is doing imo.

[Boxing_1013]

say this...





but then does this...





... omg...

Canelo had no one round in either fight where he significantly outlanded GGG...I just can't really take anyone seriously who says Nelo had 5 clear rounds...in the first fight of all things...just wild imo...and that's me saying that Nelo did not have 1 round where he significantly outlanded GGG, not necessarily compubox...though compubox had basically the same numbers I do when I watch those fights, and they often times get it right.

If someone really hates GGG they can try and say he didn't 'live up to expectations' vs Nelo and even Jacobs...but to say he didn't win those fights quite clearly...I mean just very biased imo.

Also I have never really said a bad word about Nelo or DJ or any other fighter on here...if I critique a guy/his resume, I do it without resorting to name-calling of him, and still give them credit where it is due...I don't get my self-worth out of my guy winning or the 'other' guy losing, so I don't really give two sh.its about who wins a fight when it starts...just let the best man win...these dudes are getting beat up for our entertainment...the least we can do is acknowledge who the better man was when it is quite clear.

[Curtis Harper]

Good post man...for the record, I only cite compubox when it more or less backs up what I see in the ring...which makes sense in a way...I think all compubox is, is two guys counting the punches, one for each guy...most of the time those guys get it about right, since that is all they are looking for...but sometimes they seem to miss a lot of the work that one of the guys is doing imo.

If robots could count punches, they'd be judges

The human element leaves room for error. This is why is used ''usually''.

When a so called fight fan defends a clear robbery (because either their guy received the gift or the victim is a fighter they hate), that fan should start wearing dresses and peddle their ass at $5 a pop. Half if the customer has a coupon.

[Boxing_1013]

Anything other than a KO.

Guarantee someone will be crying robbery.

unreasonable boxing fans looking for a reason to complain

Unfortunately that would be how it seems...your image prompted another thought of mine...I thought Fury-Wilder was a draw...not really seeing how people had Fury clearly winning that many rounds in that fight...and Wilder with the 2 10-8 rounds gave himself a chance...just the all over reaction of some fans in these fights is weird imo.

Like to me it is obvious when it is a close fight...and when there is a clear winner.

[Boxing_1013]

When a so called fight fan defends a clear robbery (because either their guy received the gift or the victim is a fighter they hate), that fan should start wearing dresses and peddle their ass at $5 a pop. Half if the customer has a coupon.

yeah that's kind of my feeling too...I honestly don't care one bit if the guy I like going in wins...if he is good enough he will win, if not the other guy wins, who gives a sh.it...just call it like you see it ya know