No, "in their prime" has no barring in p4p, p4p is based on CURRENT form. As in, RIGHT NOW. What's so hard to understand about this?
What you are talking about is not p4p ranking, it is ALL TIME ranking or ATG ranking.
Or let me put it like this, if you say it's p4p, then it is all time p4p ranking, in which case said list would also include retired fighters like Duran, Mayweather, Leonard, Robinson, Ali, Foreman, etc.
But the list that everyone here is talking about and the analists are talking about is not the same one you're talking about.
That list is about who is the best now. Whether you're in your prime or not has no bearing on the issue. It is if you can beat everyone NOW, at your CURRENT form.
Tweet
Comment