How high do you rank pacman on the ATG list?????

[tdubb]

I hate people who say floyd is the greatest of all time but geeze.....if pac is top 5 to u floyd is litterally number 1. And I am not joking .. since when does beating thurman a guy whose been inactive and almost got knocked out in his last fight lol how does that make him greatest 5 of all time lol do u guys even have a top of 10 of all time? How.....

Would you rank Ken Norton ahead of Ali?

Or Buster Douglas ahead of Mike Tyson?

[johnbook]

I've got:

Ali
SRR
Armstrong

Then next I'd have to ponder between SRL, Pac and Duran

Longevity, moving up in weight have a lot to do with it.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Lower end top 10. Gonna re-evaluate my list this week

[spenz]

This fight is now clearly turning the tide in Manny's standing in ATG ranking. People have now a clearer assessment of his greatness.

Julio Cesar Chavez said he is now the GOAT.

Barrera said unapologetically that Manny to him is now 2nd to Ali.

Kawhi Leonard who has never bothered with these things or anything nonsensical really personally made an effort to come to Pacquiao and had a picture as a souvenir just said "Manny is now the Michael Jordan, the new Kobe Bryant, the new Lebron James of Boxing." Kawhi we know is a casual fan but this guy has a steely character and every word that comes from his mouth has gravitas.

Same thing in all of sports,--You can only be the GOAT if people especially your fellow boxers start proclaiming you as the GOAT."

Man I tell you he's so close.. so damn close, one more impossible win ..

To me he's not yet the GOAT, but who the **** am I compared to the lion of Culiacan--Julio Cesar Chavez and all those great people. My opinion clearly does not move a needle.

[IronDanHamza]

He just moved up past Vinny Pazienza with that epic performance last night

Really though we were spoiled this era with Pacman and Floyd in the same era.

I had £200 on Thurman. Not because I dom'r rate Pacman, I rate him massively as one of the best I've seen. But at age 40? Couldn't see it. But he did. Amazing.

[GrandpaBernard]

anyone got Mike Tyson's opinion

He's a boxing historian in addition to being an ATG heavyweight champ

[Mooshashi]

Top 10 for sure. Can't put him above Ali, SRR, Greb. Beyond that, put him anywhere up to 10 is fine by me.

[FredWreck]

Top 5. Too many accomplishments and he delivers ass beatings every time. He dropped Keith Thurman 1st round.

[Htown-Finest]

Lower end top 10. Gonna re-evaluate my list this week

What this guy said ^

[-Antonio-]

Clearly top 10. The guy has put together an incredible resume. He has been extremely resilient. Thurman clearly best Porter and Garcia. 1 year ago he was the man at WW. We cant forget that. And Manny beat him clearly.