More impressive resume. Joe Calzaghe or marciano?

[The Problem]

marciano has few more wins but which fought better comp?

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Tough question both guys most notable wins came against guys who were no longer at their peak. I’d probably edge Marciano but would be fine with others picking Calzaghe.

[Cutthroat]

Marciano was #1 in his division.

Calzaghe is probably the 5th best guy to fight at 168. Ward, Froch, RJJ, Toney, rank ahead of him, possibly even Jean Pascal . David Benavidez could pass him up very soon too.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Marciano was #1 in his division.

Calzaghe is probably the 5th best guy to fight at 168. Ward, Froch, RJJ, Toney, rank ahead of him, possibly even Jean Pascal . David Benavidez could pass him up very soon too.

Froch😂😂
Calzaghe was a far superior fighter, just look at either of their fights against a prime Kessler.

Are you also trying to suggest Marciano is the #1 HW of all time???

Surely trolling...

[ShaneMosleySr]

Marciano beat Archie Moore, Jersey Joe Walcott twice, Ezzard Charles twice and knocked out Joe Louis.

The end!

[BoloShot]

Calzaghe had 23 title defenses I believe and some against some really top top opponents so I'd give it to him on that merit.

[Cutthroat]

Froch😂😂
Calzaghe was a far superior fighter, just look at either of their fights against a prime Kessler.

Are you also trying to suggest Marciano is the #1 HW of all time???

Surely trolling...

Kessler & Froch are entirely different fighters, Calzaghe NEVER fought someone with Froch's power+class and no a shot Eubank dropping 20lbs on a week's notice doesn't count.

Look at Maidana-Mayweather, nobody thought he'd stand a chance.

And I said Marciano was #1 in his division at that time, Joe wasn't, he may not have even been top 5.

[Htown-Finest]

Marciano .



Calzaghe was a good fighter tho that gets forgotten a lot.

[DreamFighter]

Marciano was #1 in his division.

Calzaghe is probably the 5th best guy to fight at 168. Ward, Froch, RJJ, Toney, rank ahead of him, possibly even Jean Pascal . David Benavidez could pass him up very soon too.

5th is maybe a litttlehigh, be honest.

he is in the top five smw for britain though if thats what you mean,

[DreamFighter]

obv marciano, hes atg.

marciano had retired younger than the age that Joe C won his first legit title, fcks sake, theres no comparison between the two.